Take_my_Revolution

I saw that speculation about Jen. It showed up on my dash on tumblr. The person made it seem like a fact when there was no evidence. Emma being pregnant could make for an interesting fanfic.

Austenphile

Seriously? Jen has the flattest stomach. People can be so unthinking.

Mace

How could Emma be pregnant? Captain Swan won't get to have "coffee" until the series finale at the rate they are going.

Though I would totally be ok with a fanfic where she is.

Miss Cam

To be fair, Hook and Emma could totally have done it and the writers just decided not to show it. I mean, Snow and Charming probably have a lot a lot of true love's 'rest' and we've had just one scene of them with implied naughty times. This is not a show with a lot of bed scenes. So a pregnancy can't be discounted just because we haven't seen a couple actually at it.

That said, there has been no hints on the show of Emma being pregnant in any way. I did see that original speculation about Emma being pregnant that I think Jen's tweets are refering to and yeah, the zooming in on pictures to prove pregnancy and all that... Ugh. No. Not a fan of stating theories as fact in general and even less so when it's about an actor's apperance.

wild sage growing

It's a whooooooole lot of things.

But mostly it's just sad. And horribly sexist.

T'Lynn

All of this. It's fine to speculate the character might be pregnant because there has been no confirmation one way or another of CS sexy times. But saying an actress looks pregnant when she's not. That is so rude and hurtful.

Austenphile

So much this statement. I have had so many friends cry because someone thought they were pregnant when they weren't. It's just awful.

samantha24

I think that if anything like that happened with CS they would put it on screen like they did with OQ and yes we can assume that snowy had sex at some point but they did show them together on screen for the audience when the first got together so i think for the first time they will show it on screen

I don't think people were saying the actress was pregnant they were saying the character was pregnant which explains her comments that emma swan was not pregnant (i think emma has enough issues)

Austenphile

They might show it or it might have already happened offscreen. I can see it either way. We didn't "see" David and Mary Margaret's "affair" during the curse. And it was somewhat debated until Snow confirmed they slept together when he believed he was married to Kathryn in 4.08. We saw Snowing after the EF trip, and it was implied on their honeymoon after their official/ second wedding, but that's really it. Many debate whether or not they'd had sex before their first wedding given David's reaction to Snow's comments when the necklace started moving. We never saw Rumbelle having sex. She has been woke up alone in his bed twice but that's it. I honestly don't know which way they are playing it.

confessor_meggy

Definetely haven't heard any of this Not nice at all.

I don't think they'll necesseraly show their first time (If it hasn't happened yet.). With Snowing and Rumbelle there were hints of their first time occurring, but I guess it wasn't properly appointed. Snowing had wedding and Emma in ep1, and Rumbelle had Belle waking up in Rumple's bed in S2 and looking at his side.

I think the only esplicit first we had were OQ, and on some degrees David Nolan and Mary Margaret in S1

Randysgirl

I can't believe someone actually zoomed in on her stomach as evidence... Good grief.

I can see the argument on both sides for CS having done (or not done) the do. Although if Jen says it's 100% certain that Emma isn't pregnant, I'll probably lean more to not yet. You can only be a hundred percent sure if you haven't done anything, right?

fox24

Lol. I do think Cs had coffee after Emma threw him on the bed

Mace

With her parents downstairs listening? Yick.

earthspirits

I would prefer that the writers be a little more obvious in showing CS as having had "coffee" (I want to see that scene in one form or another! Even if only in flashback). Also, I don't really want their first "coffee" time to be when she's in full-on Dark One mode.

That "fan" was pretty nervy to send that to Jen (and yeah, her tummy is as flat as can be, so one can only wonder what that person thought they were "seeing"). Darned rude, that's for sure. And even if it turned out to be true, certainly none of their business.

As for the writers making the character of Emma pregnant - while later in the show this could be an interesting development - at the moment, I think such a plot "twist" might not fly. As we go into S5, it would just seem like a re-hash of what they are already doing with Zelena (assuming, of course, that Z. isn't lying through her teeth - which I wouldn't put past her).

fox24

Oh riight I forgot about that