Caliina

Loved

NB scene it was awsome! He was so cute, asking about Chase More NB scenes!!! Need that! I allready knew about the tape, so wasn't suprised....
I always was a NB shipper, so can't say I totally hated it

CB Brooke finally found a good guy. I love that they don't have to have big makeout scenes, they so don't need it. Just a small kiss here and there. And they are still the cutest couple ever. But it was abit off when he called her "my girl", it reminded me to much when Lucas used to call Brooke "pretty girl".

Now I only need to see the Brooke/Rachel scenes

hotchad

I loved the episode !!! great job both with the writting & directing !

Lucas & Peyton pwn my soul . They really make me believe in true love. at first when Lucas lied to Peyton about the book , I was ready to be pissed , not something that LP will do , but then , He told her the truth . the way it is with LP , no matter what , they have a great friendship & they know eachother so well , I love Peyton & the way she didn't call on his lie . the way He opened up to her ...oh they bring out the best out of eachother . I LOVED all those little LIAGH throw backs , the parallel between the Books & Music ...the Bed room scene in Dan's bed room , Thank you for letting Peyton say this thing to him .
The scene in Lucas's bed room was my favorite ...Chad & Hilarie need to talk about this , seriously ,lol , this two are SO beyond amazing together ! they have such powerful chemistry , I love, love ,love thier scenes together, they portray LP in such a real way.I thank them for it . great job ! btw...thanks for those close ups on the nose touchs & lips touchs ...:::dies:::

Lucas & Dan - it really breaks my heart to know Lucas try to put down his defenses with Dan , only for him to be devastated again after he'll discover Dan killed Keith . Chad's expression were so powerful , great job.
Chad really rocked this episode imo. Great acting.
I loved the Nate & Lucas scene as well, for once He's there for Lucas . that's was a sweet scene.

Peyton - I love her. this episode was the essence of Peyton in my eyes. she is such a gold hearted person .All her scens with Lucas, her saying Hi to Glenda at the party , I'm not a fan of P\B but that was a good scene, the way she signed those papers, the way she told brooke , "you know I love him...I didn't mean my love for him to hurt you"- perfect ! Hil nailed it - big time ! great writting, great acting ! .

I liked Haley a lot this episode - a bit of the old Haley *yay* . I loved Her & Skillz - really great friendship ...they have a good vibe going on .

Rachel - I love her . I loved Her scene with Brooke . She almost brought tears to my eyes.

I think I'm going to watch the episode again in the 10385748 time lol...

Israfel

LP is one of the main reasons i keep watching this show, and last epi they were amazing!

I hated Brooke so much, let Rachel taking the fall and all the crap, and lying to Haley who got fired btw--that sucks a lot!--

I loved Rachel and i felt really bad for her, that girl's sometimes a bitc*, but she didn't deserve all the things she got through! The scene with the highschool boxes was heartbreaking!

I felt really bad for Mouth too, Lee did an amazing job!

I won't even comment for the sextape!

Swamy

All the episode for me was worth just because of the sprinklers scene I found it SO damn cute, I hope to see ther friendship grow, and I'm sorry to see people is bothered by this scene, I think it's totally innocent, I go tired to see him interacting always with the same people os for me it's a good change

QuinCess

I have only seen one scene. And that was the Haley slapping Rachel scene. It was good, actually really good. I loved the fact that Haley told her things plain and simple! Skills owns my heart, he is such a great friend. I already have a Haley, now I just want to find my own, Skills.

I have only read stuff about the episode, and it made me realise that this show is no longer sticking to the actual premise. What happened to the two brothers whose worlds collided? For me this show has become a horrible book where the mid section is long winded, which makes me want to put the book back on the shelf. There is no need to read the ending when everything in between doesn't make sense.

They were two brothers, one had everything, and the other lived on the wrong side of the tracks. But now the tracks have clashed and I have no idea how. It is quite sad.

luvravens

The Good

-Haley putting Rachel in her place. LOVED it!! It was like season 1 Haley is back
-Loved the Naley scenes. SO cute on the couch. They are at their best when they are supporting each other. Also so sweet when Nathan felt the baby kick for the first time. The expression on his face when he says "Wow" was just so great!
-Brooke/Chase scenes. For some reason I reallly like this couple.
-Mouth/Skillz/Nathan bonding. Always good to bring in the Rivercourt guys.
-I'm glad that Skillz/Haley are able to have a few scenes.

The Bad

-Lucas/Peyton. For some reason they just bother me. Too much blonde. I liked them in season 1, but watching them now something just seems off.
-Shelly/Mouth got way too much screen time. Hi we just met lets have sex. Wow, Mouth sometimes it takes a few weeks before people sleep together. I mean you are only in high school. The storyline just seemed rushed to me.


THE VERY BAD

-The sex tape. Why is it neccesary to rewrite history. Nathan and Brooke sleeping together. This came for nowhere! I'm all for the Brooke/Nathan/Naley friendship, but now it just seems tainted. She has always been their biggest supporter and now it comes out that they slept together and this piece of information just never came up. Really, are we supposed to believe that. Also water scenes are for Naley. I really didn't like the sprinkler scenes AT ALL!!!

loveatlanta

Not my favorite episode by any means but that had nothing to do with the "sex tape". It seemed to be more of a filler episode to me. It did have it's moments though that I really enjoyed.

* Nathan/Skillz/Mouth - I enjoyed them together. I am glad to see them get more screen time. Skillz was so funny calling Deb the "alcoholic easter bunny"!

* Mouth/Shelly - Man, just when you think that Mouth is going to get a girl. Poor guy! I don't know, I think she will change her mind. Lee did some awesome work.

* Nathan/Haley - Being the huge Naley fan that I am, I could have used more Naley time. Lots more but I will not complain. I watch the show as a whole. I loved the apartment scene. Nathan picking the lint off her sock. Haley playing with his hair. They looked very married. James was looking hot in that shirt he was wearing too, btw! The whole baby kicking scene was cute. I thought it was silly to let Nathan feel the kick for the first time at the party. I think he would have done that before now. I am not sure of what the timeline is from last week to this one but I thought it was dumb!!

* Haley/Rachel - I really enjoyed Haley slapping Rachel. So overdue!!! Danielle and Joy played that scene well.

* Lucas/Peyton - I am enjoying these two. I like them together.

* The Sex Tape - Not as bad as I was lead to believe. I don't hold this again Nathan or Brooke. In fact, this was very much Season 1 for these characters. We don't know yet, but if Nathan remembers this and just didn't tell Haley, than he was wrong. Until then, he gets a pass from me! The tape itself looked like they only took one take on it. Maybe they were trying to make it look like an amateur did it.

* Dan - Dan is so after Karen. I expect them to get together before the season ends. I want to see that actually! I know, what is wrong with me?

* Rachel - I felt sorry for Rachel last night. I have never been a Rachel hater. In fact. every show needs a Rachel. But when she opened her closet and there were all these boxes with high school names on them....I was sad for her!!

You know, I think I liked the episode better than I thought after typing all this out! If only we could get our ratings up. The CW as a whole needs to do something. Of course, AI is killing everyone!

mary7roses

Alright, so my take on this episode....

Lucas and Peyton- I am such the LPer, I couldn't help but love thier scenes.... Peyton running out on him to turn of the "NP" Sex tape, priceless... I loved it, it was quite funny....

Haley/Skills- I never realized until these past two episodes how close of friends these two are, I am glad they are soo close!! I love Skills sticking up for Haley, its great!!

Haely/ Rachel- I loved it.... Haley did good!! I'm glad she was able to get all that out of her system, too bad some of it was aimed at the wrong person, well kind of... either way, great Job Haley!!

Brooke/Nathan- Loved it!! I loved thier sprinkler scene, so cute!! And their sex tape!!! Scandelous!!!! Can't wait to see all the reactions next week!!

Brooke/Peyton- I can't help but LOVE their friendship, it's kinda like a friendship I amn going through right now, minus the whole cheating thing.... But these two literally always put me in tears, I can't help it, I get very emotional... When brooke went to Peyton about her drawings, I was crying becasue peyton was just like yeah, here you go, this is huge for you, I'd do anythig to help you, I loved it, couldn't help but cry, I know I am a sissy, oh well..... I can't wait to see what happens between these two next week!!!

Nathan/ Lucas- I love how they are there for each other, nice brotherly love!!

Lucas- He seriously needs to kick Dans A$$, find out it was him and then go psycho on him, could you guys tell that Lucas could tell something was weird about Dan, the way he was acting and everything, Lucas had that "sherlock holmes" look on his face, especially when Dan was tlaking to him about Karen when Karen was listening in.... Dan SOOOO Needs to be exposed!!!

Mouth/Shelly- I couldn't BELIEVE they did it, I mean shes a clean teen (with history, yes but still) and Mouth is, well, MOUTH.... I totally couldn't believe that he had sex with her and shes a clean teen, he should've talked with her more and stuff, I still am in shock over this..... OMG!!!

Rachel- I feel kinda bad for her and kinda not, shes still the REachel we love to hat4e, but she has grown up and her stepping up like that for Brooke was a great gesture!! I still want Brooke to come forward though....

Brooke/ Chase- I love these two and I hope theres a future tyhere, Chase seems to be really good for Brooke!!

I'm done!!

bbcountry

I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVED NATHAN&BROOKE!!!
You can leave now, Chase.

Peyton&Lucas, still LOVE Beautiful couple.

Mouth: I have no words.

Rachel: I'm sad for her, but I think she deserves it.

Haley&Skills: great friendship

wayliz

My Review: Contrived and Shallow


Well unfortunately this episode continued the S4 trend of lazy storytelling and poorly written dialogue and interaction.

I might acutally enjoy watching L/P and Chase/Brooke if either of those relationships had been properly developed and not just fallen out of the sky.

I might have actually enjoyed watching the Mouth/Shelley stuff if those two had had more than a few scenes together leading up to this. Again, not invested in their stuff because the writers have been lazy.

I might have actuallt felt sorry for Rachael if she had done ANYTHING leading up to this that could have remotely been considered human. But at this point, she's gotten off easy for all of the things she's done leading up to this.

I might have not wanted to throw something at my T.V. while Brooke and Nathan were frollicking in the sprinklers if we had had even an inkling that these two knew each other existed before this episode. Jump on the Insta-Friends train that always seems to run through Tree Hill, Brooke and Nathan. Contrivance is SOOoooo annoying.

I never would have enjoyed watching the porn tape....no matter who's drunken hook-up it was. This storyline was so far out of left field I think I saw Sammy Sosa walking by in the party scene (yeah, I know he's a right fielder, but still). Not only was it completely random, it was completely unnecessary if the writers would actually do their jobs. The could have brought Brooke and Peyton back together in friendship in a meaningful way of they had committed to investing some actual time into their reconciliation.

Alas, it is all flash and no substance

ETA: The NB fans do realize that after next week, Nathan and Brooke are going to go back to forgetting each other exist, right?

OTHfan4ever

I LOVE NATHAN AND HALEY SO MUCH !!!!!
The apartment scene was LOVE
James and Joy were great. Their chemistry is so amazing !!!!!!!!!!!!! They are so natural together... AWESOME.
I MISS NALEY...

javajunkie4eva88

I thought that this episode was very good and very entertaining........except for the Mouth/Shelly parts. And I also don't care for the Dan/Karen parts just b/c I know he killed Keith.

But Lucas and Peyton own my soul. I loved their scenes more then I'm willing to admit and I love how their relationship is forming. They communicate, they're honest with eachother, they know when the other person's lying, and still don't press the issue, and they.are.HAWT. Chad and Hil's chemistry still amazes me.

Truthfully, I haven't been disappointed with any of the episodes from 4.08 on.

sofiasam

about this episode .. what i think .....


NALEY : i really loove them !! i could say that naley is why i love this episode and why i love the show ..
I really really love JOY in the 4.14 like everytime !! she is a such amazing and beautiful girl !!! and she's incredibly talented !!! Joy did a great job in this episode!
The apartment scene was just so amazing !! i really love this scene in the couch !! James and Joy are so talented !! i love their chemistry , they are so simply and narural together and it's so good to see this !! its a great pleasure !!!!!!! Nathan and Haley are so cute !!!! i want to see more scene like this !!! i hope we see more in the next episodes !!!!
I love the kicking scene ... when nathan touch her belly ... so cute !! like i said they are so cute together !!!!
i could say sincerly that i really love this episode only for all NALEY part !!!! their scene are so cute and i love see them together and i hope that we will have more scene with naley together !!!! because I think that we have less scene naley and I have misses NALEY so much.
AH i forget ... James is so so sexy i love him !!! lol

Haley /Rachel : I love the haley/rachel scene !!! I love when haley slapped rachel !! sincerly i was happy because for the first time she was irritated !! and it was good to see her like that !! she 's unbelievable !!!
Haley think that its' Rachel the guilty one. but she 's misleads... I hope that haley will discover it soon because poor Rachel does not deserve all this stuff! for the first time since i love her !! and i don't want her to go !!

Mouth/ Shelly : poor mouth ... it's so sad !! it's so unfair .. why he couldn't have a great girl who's love him ...

but I don't like leyton scene even if i think that lucas and peyton are a cute couple !! i love them but .... i can't .. i can't ... always see them kissing it's too much .. but like i said before it's a cutie couple but too much leyton i don't think it's great ....

Chase / Brooke ... no comment .... too much cheesee !!!

infinite memory

all in all, I think the episode was good. it could have been better, yes.. but it is definately my second favorite episode of s4.

Naley I can't really recall any Naley in this episode. Blah. I remember them talking about Deb, and them talking at the party. That's about it. But of course, they were cute as always.

Rachel I felt bad for her, period. There's really not much else to say, is there? She was wrong for initiating stealing the test, but it was still Brooke who went along with it. Part of me kind of thinks it's karma coming back to bite her for all she'd done through s3 and the first half of s4?

Haley/Rachel As much as I felt bad for Rachel, Haley was hilarious. I love these two, because it's refreshing to see two new enemies (okay, they're not all that new, but.. you know what I mean) that I actually look forward to watching.

Lucas/Peyton Meh. I kind of feel like their scenes are a little too cheesy for my taste. I kind of feel like Mark is rushing their storyline, no matter how long they've known eachother. I'm not buying it

Mouth/Shelly Seeing Mouth lose is virginity to someone I really, really, really do not like kind of urked me. And the way Shelly treated him afterwards.. Ugh. I hated it. I didn't like them to begin with, but now I just hope Ms. Clean Teen poofs forever.

Nathan/Brooke I think the sex tape was kind of.. random and unnecessary. I've never really shipped them much, so seeing that they've had stuff go on between them seemed kind of strange. Although, the sprinkler scene was beyond adorable.

Brooke/Chase Saved the best for last I love these two. And I love finally being able to see Brooke happy with someone.

mary7roses

I know you all are saying that the sex tape came out of left field, Iyt sure as hell did, but how often does this show have things that come out of left field, ALL THE TIME!!!!!!!!!! So I don't see how this is any different.... I like the sex tape storyline, it shows that brooke is a total hypocrite.... I think its going to bring a lot of drama and I miss drama, especially since Dan went all :"nice Pretty Boy", I miss mean Dan!!!!!!!

To My "It shows that Brooke is a total hypocrite"... I wanted to state here that I love Brooke and her character, the reason I stated this was because I am excited to see how this storyline goes down, and since we all have seen how much Brooke is against cheating, now we saw her cheat and her "dirty little secret" (I love that song...LOL) is out and I for one can not wait to see the outcome of this, so just a reminder, I LOVE BROOKE!!!!!