Jennifer ~*Justified1/2*~

Yea that was a great scene and a nice ending to the episode.

~Maz~

I think he has changed is ways. he hasnt done anything jackass-y for the last 3 eps (since sleeping with nikki). and peyton already knew about him sleeping with a random girl, she just found out now that it was nikki.

Also i agree girls shouldnt let guys come between them. but once one of the friends betrays you by kissing the guy behind your back, i think he's pretty much come between you already. i love the brooke/peyton friendship btu i dont think brooke can or should trust peyton again.

Sexy C

First off Nathan and Haley I love because she makes him a better person. They look so sweet together.

Peyton has no right to be mad with Lucas for sleeping with Nikki. Lucas was single. He had just broke up with Brooke and because he thought he was going to have something with her. But being the person she is she decides after she has ruin someone else relationship it is not worth it. What a great friend she is. I think that it was her that got whipped not Nikki. And what was up with Nikki getting that great lick in and then wrestling on the floor and pulling hair. That made the fight so weak. I do think that Nikki is crazy though.

I am happy that Keith is moving on with his life because Karen does not desire him. I thought she was this great person when the show first started and now the truth is starting to come out. Keeping a father from his son because he does not want you and then making the son believe that it was the father that wanted nothing to do with him. That is down right dirty. Dan is still not my favorite person though. And Deb is crazy for thinking that they were going to work things out. She should have got us and then put him out instead of the other way around.

The scene with Brooke going to Peyton and saying sorry was very sweet. But it was not right. I think in the future they should have become friends again but this is way to soon. Brooke was betrayed by the one person in the world who should always have her back. If she does it once she will do it again. And for the people think that Brooke was wrong for going after Lucas you are wrong. She did ask Peyton if she was interested and Peyton said" he is free game".
What kind of friend tells you that then goes behind your back with him. That is skanky to me. In my own personal life I would never to my best friend and I would never forgive her if she did.
Lucas has changed a little but just like Nathan got a good woman to make him want to be a better person. Lucas needs one too. When he had Haley for a close friend he was the best but now she is with Nathan he has no one to keep him a good guy.
All together I love the eppy and looking forward to next week. Can not wait to see how he acts when he finds out Dan wanted to spend time with him and his mother said no.

Nathans girl

I have to agree with Maz, hehe I find it amusing that ur so pro-lucas, and I'm so pro-nathan, it's fun sparring, but I agree on the Peyton front, I was proud of Lucas this ep for the kindness he showed, and the protectiveness he showed towards Nathan. Peyton shouldn't have been THAT mad, she knew he hooked up with a random woman from a bar, the only difference is now she knows it was Nikki, Lucas did not deserve to be layed into.

Not meaning I didn't love Peyton this ep, I used to really dislike Peyton but she's really growing on me, good job writers!

TVGEEK

OMIGOD!!! This epi was so great in so many ways. I mean there were tender moments, raging catfights and Tim [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img].

Ok, so I'l start with Peyton. I've never been the biggest Toaster fan in the world but last night she one me over. I mean the "Oh that's skank and it's coming from you." was classic. And she was b!tchen during the catfight. Now, I, being a female, in no way, under normal cirumstances condone catfights. I think they make all girls seem b!tchy and mean but Nikki was just asking to get her a$$ kicked.

Which brings me to my next topic. Nikki. How many ways can you say PSYCHO!!!! I mean the girl is definently off her knocker. At first I didn't hate her as much cause she was just a girl trying to make up for her mistakes, but then.... She just went all Joan Crawford and started scaring the ***** out of me.

Now onto Brooke. In the beginnig I was like could things get no worse for her. I mean she walked up to Haley being friendly and Haley just shot her down. It was just so sad to kind of watch it go down. Then there was the party where I was shocked to discover Nikki was like Brooke's new best friend. I mean the situation just screamed "Gonna end horribly"
Then there was the whole Brooke standing up for Peyton which was so sweet, and the reconciliation between the two was even sweeter.

And I would now like to welcome Lucas to the "Man Whore" club. I mean come on you have to admit the little one night stand between him and Nikki was just like 'ICK'. Though I did love the fact that he and Nathan started to become a little closer.

This epi was chalked full of "AWWW!" Nathan/Haley moments. I mean the telling Tim to get out in unison, the cuddle walk at the end, it was all just so sweet. But I smell trouble in paradise for Naley due to the preview. Cause you know that Haley's not just gonna let the "Porn Site" thing go, and frankly I don't blame her.

The only thing that was missing from this epi was some good old-fashioned Jeyton (Jake/Peyton) moments. I think that they're the sweetest together.

~Maz~

hehe. eah sparring is fun. but im pro-nathan too. but everyone is pro nathan these days so i dont really need to stick up for him. i just feel the need to stick up for lucas because everyone hates him for making mistakes. not that i dont blame him too, but in specific circumstances. i blame the writers, they made lucas too perfect and good at the start that everyone was so mad when he finally slipped up and made mistakes.

*^*Laur*^*

Yup, I totally agree..I still don't like him though. I used to like him in the beginning, but now everything he does annoyes me. Even the way he says his lines pisses me off. Do I k now why? Nope, have no clue. But, I have a major Nathan obsession. Nathan's it for me. Nobody else can take his place.

As for the porn thing, I think it's stupid. But oh well, they need a storyline so I guess that'll do. Couldn't they think of anything better though? Jeez...PORN? Come on now.

Xandra20

Why they didn't put something about Nikki kidnaping Jenny in the preview? [img]smilies/frown.gif[/img]

LovinLafferty_23

one thing . poor lucas !!
i think its ironic that peyton knew that he slept with someone and was okay with it, but when she found out that someone was nikki, she was mad. its not like he knew that Nikki and Peyton would become enemys or that Nikki was Jake's ex. i dont think he'd wouldve slept with her if he knew.

brooke / peyton - i liked how peyton stopped trying to say sorry. was it just me or did you guys notice that when peyton said she was tired of saying sorry and trying to talk to Brooke, Brooke started to realize what a great friend she'd lost ?

nathan - [img]smilies/lol.gif[/img] loved it when he threw gave the preztel to dan

Nikki - one word .. physco

lucas / nathan - i liked how they're beginning to bond [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

and of course . love the naley scenes.. but they should have more of those

overall good ep [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img]

Rosebud55

I forgot about Nathan giving the pretzel to Dan, that was so funny. [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

..:*babi_gurl311*:..

Peyton totally kicked ass last night! The scenes with her and Lucas reminded me how much I loved seeing them together... and when she told Brooke off, I felt kinda of sad and glad at the same time. I mean she keeps saying sorry and sorry to Brooke over and over again, but nothing. So there's only so much you can do... and I felt sad when I saw Brooke's expression after their scene because I know how much Brooke want Peyton to keep saying she's sorry, so they can be friends again.

Haley and Nathan, oh so cute... I love the scene in her bedroom and his apartment! Even though we didn't get any 'action' between them, I thought their scenes were cute! Anyways, James was a hottie, and Bethany was just so adorable. I loved her expression when Nikki and Brooke came to the party, what a cute face she has!

Dan and Deb scene was scary!! I thought that was too much... Keith and Karen are getting pretty boring, and I can't believe that Keith's leaving... I'm going to miss the guy.

Nikki is a psycho, she scared me last night, I liked her before, but now I don't know what to say.

Overall, last night wasn't that great, I expected more, the only scenes that were great was Nathan and Haley, and Nikki and Peyton cat fight.

~Audrey~

All right, last night's episode was great, I love that they now have like an even amount of screen time for each character, like they're not totally pimping CMM. My two cents:

Lucas: God forgive me, I actually liked him last night. He has been a total ass lately, but he's slowly getting to be his old self again. I felt bad for him cause he was paying for his past mistakes all over again, so sad, but he did have some pretty great scenes last night. I know that some people are pro-Lucas while others are pro-Nathan, I loved Lucas at the beginning, but it's now all about Baby James! Speaking of...

Nathan: I want a Nathan for myself! Is it possible that I love him even more now? I loved Peyton's line about how he and Lucas switched places, so true! Nathan is the sweetest guy ever! He looked so adorable wearing his hat backwards and in his uniform. *sigh* I also loved how he gave Dan that pretzel from the ground. too funny for words. He and Gary had some nice scenes too. I felt so bad for him though, going to jail for doing nothing at all. Did anyone else notice that when he came into his apartment, he was holding some sort of boxy thing, do you know what he was holding?

Peyton: I really did love her, she had some pretty great lines. "high five" "skank" "Haley James, party girl!" too many to write down. I loved that she had a list of all the CDs she was missing on the back of the door, I thought that that was so cute! I also loved her green tank-top that she wore to the party. That fight with Nicki, she so beat that psycho, at first I didn't mind Nicki, but now, she's just a bitch.

Haley: I love her! I loved her pink top that she wore, it was so cute. I love her developing friendship with Peyton also. She is slowly becoming more and more popular, and I actually don't mind the character change. She deserves some nice, healthy girlfriends. That was so her "coming-out party."

Brooke: She was seriously pissing me off for most of the episode, but then her telling Nicki to leave and that conversation she had with Peyton, all my Brooke love came back. I also liked how she totally took responsibility for Nicki, although it was mainly Nicki's fault.

Nathan/Haley: Could they get any cuter, they will and always will be, my favorite couple in the history of television. Four times in two weeks? wow. I thought it was hysterical how they were both like "Go home, Tim." made me chuckle.

Lucas/Nathan: Very nice bonding scenes. When they were practicing b-ball, it was a very nice line that Nathan made, and I loved how Lucas defended Nathan, not once, people, but twice. They're slowly developing a, should I call it friendship? I also like how the writers are making it happen slowly, not all of a sudden "Hi, bro, wanna come over?" It takes time. Good job, writers!

Lucas/Peyton: They are my second favorite couple on the show. My heart went out for both of them. We all know that Peyton knew that Lucas had already slept with "bar ****" but I think it was just the confirmation AND the fact that it was Nicki (the girl that she just got in a fight with) hurt her even more. The line at the end was so sad, yet so true. (I do think that Lucas isn't as bad as Nathan was, but he got pretty damn close!)

Peyton/Brooke: I did like Peyton telling Brooke that their friendship was over, I thought it made sense. She's been apologizing for, what, four episodes now? Brooke defending Peyton was nice. And their talking on the bed was very aww worthy! I want to see them bonding again, and we'll probably see that next week at the mall. Very happy.

All the adults bore the hell out of me. So I'll just say that I don't want Keith to leave, he was starting to annoy me, but he was so nice last night. I don't want to see him move!

All in all, great episode, can't wait for next week!

[ 04-28-2004: Message edited naley1220 ]

*Marissa*

Nathan- I am so in love with him! And I fall more in love with him everyday! He is just so wonderful! His scenes with Haley were(as always) adorable and I fall more in love with this couple everyday. I really feel for Nathan, but I must admit I am enjoying the Luke/Nate interaction, and hopefully we will see more of it...

Nathan/Haley- They get cuter and cuter every episode!

Lucas- He's beginning to win me back...Slowly but surely [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

Lucas/Brooke/Peyton- Welcome back Hos over Bros! We've missed you [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

Peyton/Brooke- Looking forward to seeing their friendship renewed cause honestly I've missed it! And hopefully in the end they will make their mends with Luke and the three of them can form a friendship...And just a friendship for now.

Nikki- All I can say is GO AWAY ****!

Where was Jake?

Tim- I really like his character and I want to see more of him!

Sorry that it was not very deep! Still in overload from the O.C. But when I come back from my O.C. high I'll be sure to bring some insight to the board! [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

Love Ya,
Marissa

AlexB

I probably said this before, but I'll say it again. I've been waiting for a catfight on this show to happen for the longest. I thought that it was going to be Peyton and Brooke to be truthfully honest.

Peyton rocked in this episode, the got Luke, Brooke and Nikki too. I was glad to see Peyton say "enough". It sucked that she had to do that, but how long was she going to have to say it for Brooke to believe her.

Nikki. I think that the only reason the tramp came to Tree Hill was to make trouble. She says that she wants her daughter back. What the hell is she doing out partying at a high school party when she should be trying to bond with her daughter

I missed Jake in this episode, and Nathan was awesome. Dan. Wow. That's all I can say. I love to hate this jackass, and can he get any lower?

[ 04-28-2004: Message edited AlexB ]

[ 04-28-2004: Message edited AlexB ]

cherrios

I thought Tim was funny, with his whole King Midol comment. I was actually saying to the tv, "it's King Midus Timmy." And I love the "Tim go home" line and then Tim innocent little face "what?" [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img] [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img] [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

I enjoy watching Brooke and Peyton overcoming everything and reaching a truce over their relationship. I hope they start being friends again and that Brooke is really there for Peyton when Pyshco Nikki takes off with Jenny.

Even though Jake was missing from this episode, I forgive the WB because he will for sure be in next week episode. I love that boy--he just too good looking for his own good. [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img]

I hope Nikki becoming kidnapper on Peyton's watch of Jenny does not put a damperning affect on Jake and Peyton budding relationship.