|
#76 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
|
#77 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
|
#78 | |||
Fan Forum Star
|
i started re reading this series and just finished book 1. it was such a good introduction to the story! i love that jk introduced everything slowly and made it easy for the readers to grasp. and obviously each book got more intense.
the friendship with harry/ron/hermione was the best part of the book, it was also a shining moment for hagrid who was so lovable right from the beginning. i wanted a bit more dumbledore and harry/dumbledore but that was really the only thing it lacked. its funny how short the book is though compared to the last one! haha. movies followed it very well, but an unexpected moment was definitely taking the dragon to the roof because i forgot that happened! lol... favorite secondary character was hermione. she just made me laugh and i love how she integrated herself in to the trio. they needed her. if she doesnt count as secondary then of course id say dumbledore. He's so lovable. Last edited by Alexa; 07-21-2015 at 12:51 AM |
|||
|
#79 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
It has been years since I last read this book and I want to re-read it again at some point. I do remember being really impressed with the story and wanted more of this wizarding world. I instantly did like the trio as well and Hagrid is definitely a fan favorite.
__________________
|
|||
|
#80 | |||
Fan Forum Legend
|
Awe, meeting Rowling's Magical World for the first time while reading SS/PS just gives me goosebumps thinking about it. I was so engulfed after the first chapter. My life was never the same after that. This series changed my life and in a good way.
I feel like picking up the book now this weekend and will probably do just that. |
|||
|
#81 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
Me too and mostly I'm just curious on what I'll feel now that all the books are done and going back to this book. Everything was still new and fresh so it was pretty exciting times back then.
__________________
|
|||
|
#82 | |||
Ultimate Fan
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 8,937
|
I've reread a part of SS/PS twice in the past few years, but never completed it.
But it certainly will be interesting to read it and get a perspective now eight years after the last book came out. We know what happened in the end, what will that journey to defeat Voldemort be like, going back to the very beginning? |
|||
|
#83 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
I can't believe it's been 14 years since the book was released.
__________________
|
|||
|
#84 | |||
Ultimate Fan
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 8,937
|
It has been around for 19 years here.
I have started my third attempt at rereading SS/PS today. I got up to chapter 4, right after Hagrid delivered Harry his letter and told him he was a wizard. It's strange now that having read the books, you can spoil yourself on parts that are ambiguous in the first book. I did see an error regarding Sirius, though. In the first chapter, Hagrid said he borrowed the motorbike from Sirius, and it was the night of November 1st 1981. But didn't Sirius confront Pettigrew and get sent to Azkaban that day? So how could Sirius have loaned his bike to Hagrid? Last edited by Bec =); 07-26-2015 at 02:12 PM |
|||
|
#85 | |||
Fan Forum Star
|
that is an error because didnt everyone think sirius was guilty too? so hagrid wouldn't have thought he'd want to help harry after sending voldemort to kill him. lol.
i didnt book 1 until maybe after book 3 was already released and i remember i didnt love it but i liked it okay. everyone was obsessed with the series so i guess i had more expectations from it. i guess it felt a bit childish to me at the time but it got interesting near the end of the book so of course then i wanted to read the others. and i think by book 3 i was obsessed as everyone else. but now, reading it, its amazing. i love jks writing. even though it is for kids she just has a great gift with detail and everything comes back around in the end, its awesome. |
|||
|
#86 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
Good catch Bec. Maybe Hagrid meant he borrowed it but didn't ask?
I got quite late into reading the books. I was unsure because I'm an adult when the books were released and HP is a "children's book" but it was getting some buzz and after a friend convinced me, I started reading and just couldn't stop. It came to a point where reading HP was the "coolest thing" back then that it wasn't weird for adults to be reading the books. You guys are giving me that boost to pick up the book and read it and I might just do it this weekend. __________________
|
|||
|
#87 | |||
Ultimate Fan
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 8,937
|
I wasn't into it immediately, it took some time before I was. I probably started reading it in 1999... by that point, SS/PS, CoS, and PoA were already out.
I'm on the chapter where Harry sees his parents in the Mirror of Erised. He has just opened up the wrapping containing the invisibility cloak, and the note that went along with it... was it ever revealed who gave it back to Harry? My guess it's Lupin. I mean, James wasn't trustworthy of Sirius due to paranoia; and there is a tiny chance it'd be Pettigrew. But why would Pettigrew give it to Harry and not useit to sneak out himself to find Voldemort? Lupin is the only remaining person, though he could have handed it to Dumbledore to give to Harry. Another thing, I was reading the CoS thread and I remembered the horcrux diary. I know this is SS/PS, but remember after Harry rescued Ginny from the Chamber of Secrets, Arthur yelled at her saying something like "What have I always said? Don't trust anything where you can't see its brain!" Of course, this applies to pretty much everything, but anyways,... I remembered back to when I was reading about Harry's sorting and the Sorting Hat said something like "I may not have a brain" or something like that... and yet, they trust it? Did they test it for dark spells? I think this brings up and yet closes a lot of plot holes that links the Sorting Hat to Tom Riddle's diary; which of course is revealed in Half-Blood Prince. But the issue still remains with the Sorting Hat. Last edited by Bec =); 07-27-2015 at 03:26 PM |
|||
|
#88 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
It wasn't revealed who gave the note. I just assumed it's either Sirius or Lupin (I can't see it to be Peter too honestly). But you're right that it could be Lupin seeing as James isn't trustworthy of Sirius that time.
Regarding the sorting hat, it doesn't have a brain but it contains the intelligence of the four founders and is skilled at Legilimency so that's why they trust it. Even so, the Sorting Hat has made a few errors in judgement about sorting students and it's not an "accurate" object so to speak but it does it's task. I think there's a new bit of stuff about the sorting hat on Pottermore but I can't recall it right now. __________________
|
|||
|
#89 | |||
Fan Forum Star
|
well and the sorting hat is used under the supervision of dumbledore and all the hogwarts teachers. i think what mr weasly meant is not to trust objects you come across on your own.
oh i have an answer to your question!!! on page 206 of book 3 (i literally just read it today) hagrid explains that he did speak to sirius once, and it was after harrys parents died and he couldnt believe that he spoke to him. hagrid didnt know he was the potters "secret keeper". sirius gave him the motterbike and wanted to get rid of it, hagrid thought it was suspicious. so he must have given the bike to hagrid that day before he was taken off to azkaban. so there was an explanation after all . Last edited by Alexa; 08-02-2015 at 12:42 AM |
|||
|
#90 | |||
Moderator Manager
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 709,417
|
Thanks Alex. I need to re-read POA as well.
__________________
|
|||
Bookmarks |
Tags |
discussion , harry potter |
|