If I had to pick WHO could be redeemed, I would Abraham. he's had moment's of humanity, and next week I think we will see more of it through Katrina's ordeal. Henry has been angry his whole life, being alone, believing that he was abandoned by his mother. That kind of anger is poison and it's rotted his mind.

My money for redemption is on Henry. At the end of "The Weeping Lady", I think Henry sat on the floor in Frederick's Manor and wept, not because he could not please Moloch but because he almost killed his mother. Like Ichabod said, when a soldier has fallen he always calls for his mother.

@ChakotaysLover, It was too bad Sikozu had no faith in John.

This episode gets a 7 out of 10 for me. I enjoyed Joe and Abbie together and their talk of Corbin. Their dynamic was on point and well written and believable. I loved that little move they did with their arms when they said goodbye at the end. The special effects were also great. The casting of Joe was on point.

Ichabod gaming was hysterical. #HaloIsMyBitch12 would have surely trended had it not happened at the very end.

What I didn’t like: Nick’s out-of-nowhere interest in Abbie. More of that uneven emotional writing I have spoken of in the past.
Ichabod knowing everything and everyone. It’s getting old.
Jenny being sidelined for Hawley.
Irving getting even less screen time even though his story arc is super interesting.

And though this wasn’t actually a part of the show, knowledge that YET ANOTHER episode will be devoted to rescuing Katrina. I cannot in words begin to understand why the writer/producers keep going down this road. Must Katrina always be a victim and plot device used to make the male characters feel like men? Granted, I knew in advance this was coming, but it doesn’t make it any easier to swallow. Set this woman free for the love of all that is good and holy. Truthfully, I think the writers have plugged this epic love story so much and Crane fighting for ‘something more,” that they really don’t know what to do with her once she is out.

It's not like Katrina is thinking like a wife. Ichabod needs to make a choice and STICK WITH IT. All this back and forth is getting old.

Plus on the Jeremy/Henry thing, it's possible to love someone and NOT like them. Ichabod has had a LOT dumped on him, mostly by his semi-truthful wife. Can't fault her for not telling Ichabod about Jeremy, not really.... The whole Jeremy/Henry thing is complicated, we don't KNOW all of what was done to him before he was sealed in that box.

If I had to pick WHO could be redeemed, I would Abraham. he's had moment's of humanity, and next week I think we will see more of it through Katrina's ordeal. Henry has been angry his whole life, being alone, believing that he was abandoned by his mother. That kind of anger is poison and it's rotted his mind.

I agree, after watching #5 about Icky's jilted bethrothal, Mary Wells, I saw Abraham have a concerned look about him when Jeremy/Henry talked about hurting his parents. When Abraham is by himself he is the horseman of death and goes about his end of day tasks, but when Katrina is on his mind, he forgets about this title, and works to be good for her. Katrina has awakened the little thread of humanity in him. His heart, when it beats, it beats for Katrina. She has the power over him to turn him away from Molock.
IMO

And Katrina is starting to realize this. Even if she can't turn the Horseman of death to the purpose of the Witnesses, She could have death on her side. Abraham will do ANYTHING for Katrina.

My money for redemption is on Henry. At the end of "The Weeping Lady", I think Henry sat on the floor in Frederick's Manor and wept, not because he could not please Moloch but because he almost killed his mother. Like Ichabod said, when a soldier has fallen he always calls for his mother.

Was it ever discussed how Abraham became the Horseman of Death? Was he cursed or did he sell his soul?

Please refresh my memory.