BlondieLeigh

Idk, the last three were pretty pointless.

Alexa

Chad seems super weird. lol.

I think the first 3 seasons were classic oth. Seasons 4-5 were not as good but not bad. seasons 6-8 were the worst by far imo. just so boring and repetitive. Season 9 imo was good, it kinda revived itself in the last go, and there were only 13 episodes. But i would probably group it closer to seasons 4-5.

stlavin95

I wouldn't include season 2 in classic oth tbh

Alexa

I would. Maybe you didnt like parts of it, but it was the early OTH days along with seasons 1 and 3. Before things got too crazy with drama and boring/repetitive.

Personally I liked the odd seasons way more than the even seasons. 1, 3 and 5 are my favorites. I also really enjoyed 9 and 7 was decent.

I didnt like 2, 6, or 4 all that much and 8 was awful. lol.

stlavin95

I disliked about 95% and I can't think of one storyline that I wouldn't have changed if I had the chance too.

Alexa

the only things i disliked about season 2 were:
-lack of lp scenes
-too much felix/anna
-lack of basketball

but i loved a lot of other stuff. loved BP that season. I loved the dan/keith storyline. loved andy and andy/karen. loved the au episode. loved the finale. loved 210. loved the first few episodes. loved the sleepover episode. loved 213, loved 216.. loved the NH angst. I actually didnt even mind the BL friendship (not the romance aspect though). Loved Chris Keller.

Imzadi

urgh i hated felix and anna

stlavin95

I hated:
1. Lack of Basketball
2. Brooke/Lucas
3. Dan being a cartoon villain
4. Jules/Keith
5. Haley on tour and how she was sacrificed for some drama.
6. LP going from being one of the bigger parts of the show to barely having a friendship made no sense whatsoever.
7. Felix and none of the new characters working at all (outside of Andy). Chris worked a lot better when they retooled him into a comic relief.
8. Lucas trying to take Dan down
9. Peyton supporting guest stars all season

There's probably a couple of other things I forgot too lol

The friendships that season are probably the only things I liked

Forwood4Bamon

yes. season 5-lindsay and nanny carrie ugh.
season 6-lp got boring imo. But I loved Brooke/Julian and Julian.
Season 7-Clay.
Season 8-nothing good about it.
season 9-loved seeing Lucas and Chris keller back.

BlondieLeigh

Urgh, season 2 was awful, 7-9 were a bad waste of time. The rest was all generally acceptable.

stlavin95

They were for the most part

Alexa

I loved season 5! Other than Lindsey I think there were a lot of really great things that season. Brooke finally matured. Peyton was back to being her bad ass self. LP angst/tension NH were not boring and married they actually had real struggles.

7 was decent imo I liked the new characters alright and I liked alex/julian and that SL. I also liked the haley storyline with her mom.

Season 6 I found was pretty dull but I did enjoy parts of it. There were some good episodes in there here and there. I loved Julian. LP were boring but i still enjoyed them and their storyline. I also liked Sam and her interactions with Brooke and that plot.

8 was just so bad. Im still watching it, its taking me like a year because I never feel like watching episodes lol. Every episode is so receptive and boring. Like literally nothing even happens that season lol.

I loved 9 a lot! i loved Nathan storyline, loved Chris Keller returning, Joy was phenomenal that season. The last few episodes were so great. I am sad that lP didnt come back for the finale but oh well, at least they got their happy ending in 6.

stlavin95

Season 5 had a decent start, but it got bad when the Lindsay and Carrie arcs started getting ramping up. The season would have been much better if LP and NH didn't have pointless third parties in the picture, since they had both had enough to work out regardless imo.

Forwood4Bamon

those were bad.

BlondieLeigh

I didn't find 7 decent at all. Skimmed through most of it.