Grey's Anatomy - Episode 3.02 Episode Discussion ~ I Am a Tree - Page 2

mcdreamylover · 09-25-2006, 07:30 AM

I Am A Tree is a song? Seriously? Sounds like some kind of rhyme we said back in elementary school.

IsabelAmandaEvans · 09-25-2006, 07:42 AM

I'm be darn it is a song

by Guided By Voices

Quote:

I am a tree - I show my age when I dont cry
I have the leaves that will fall off when wind blows by
Dont strip off my bark - I have been stripped of it before
Yesterdays gone and tomorrow has so much more in store

You are a bird - youre taking off in every way
Say the last word until there is nothing more to say

Dont interrupt - you know the squirrels are my friends
Get off my limb - for I will break before I bend

Im planning to see
Im planning to feel you all over me
So climb up my trunk and build on your nest
Come and get the sap out if me
I am a tree!
Fruitless and free!
No symmetry!
Touch me and see!

I am a tree - counting my rings will do no good
I wont live long but I would be with you if I could
When you take flight, remember me to one who lives there
Since you have flown, theres something special in the air
(re-zoom/busy signals from the home front)

SpySyd · 09-25-2006, 11:15 AM

I loved pretty much everything in this ep.

* The Bang scenes were great, it was awfully funny to see Burke trying to help Cristina out with his mother... but he was so clumsy and just too obvious

Perfect match with Cristina, really.

* Loved the gang talking to Bailey about Izzie. That Bailey/Izzie scene at the end was beautiful.

* Peter Paige as the "rude" patient was pretty great.

* Addison drunk? Not a very nice sight. I think she could've been used in another way...

* Really loved both Derek and Finn. The former is back to his usual cocky and charming self, very much like in S1, which is great.

* That last scene was pretty fantastic, I must say. A bit weird and stupid that Derek should take all the blame for everything that went wrong with Addie... but this changed my spirits in a second

"Oh... this is awkward." McSteamy, in all his glory... SO glad he's back.

mcdreamylover · 09-25-2006, 11:33 AM

So we can talk about the eppy since it aired in Canada? Okay then.

I can't believe Derek is apologizing for everything either. Addison is the one who started it by cheating on him with his best friend in case she has forgotten. And it looks like she got over Derek pretty quickly IMO if Mark is already there in the hotel room with her.

~*Cubby*~ · 09-25-2006, 03:56 PM

I think I liked this episode more then the first one.

I'm gonna go rewatch it and come back.

Robotica · 09-25-2006, 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by McDreamy65 (View Post)

I think that's the seal of approval on any episode, Christy. If I can watch it and honestly say Meredith didn't disappoint or particularly anger me in any big way.... it was a pretty wonderful episode.

Spoiler:

Too true...on both counts...

Quote:

I won't go into details but I love the ep and it was a nice surprise to see it almost a week early, thanks CTV.

I hear you on that...especially after a whole summer drought where new episodes are concerned...

I didn't catch the CTV airing, but saw the episode on You Tube last night thanks to Melissa, so good deal...

Thanks for keeping the spoilery talk out of here until the episode finally airs in the US on Thursday...

Quote:

i also liked that episode and tomorow i have a new one in german!

Good deal...on both counts...

Quote:

I loved this episode, I think I even liked it more then episode 1

Well put...I agree...this one felt much more like the return of the Grey's of last season...and by that, I mean more evenly balanced between humour and drama...

Quote:

Ep 3.01 was more a Lizzy story but I loved the flash backs, ep 3.02 was more you regular GA ep more balanced, if that's the right word.

This was also most certainly true...

Quote:

The last scene would have been great... if I didn't already know what was going to happen.

Well put...

Quote:

Meredith did disappoint me and anger me .

Eh, her actions made me feel kind of mixed...

Spoiler:

Interesting song choice...I have to admit...

Quote:

it was awfully funny to see Burke trying to help Cristina out with his mother... but he was so clumsy and just too obvious Perfect match with Cristina, really.

Well put...

Quote:

Loved the gang talking to Bailey about Izzie. That Bailey/Izzie scene at the end was beautiful.

Agreed...

Quote:

Peter Paige as the "rude" patient was pretty great.

Yeah, there were parts of his performance that were just classic...and even the parts where I didn't like the character so much, I have to concede that he played the part to perfection...

Quote:

Addison drunk? Not a very nice sight. I think she could've been used in another way...

Eh...I thought it was alright...for an episode...

I just hope it's not a side of Addison we start seeing on a regular basis, since in the long term, it just doesn't mesh with her character imo...

Quote:

That last scene was pretty fantastic, I must say. A bit weird and stupid that Derek should take all the blame for everything that went wrong with Addie... but this changed my spirits in a second "Oh... this is awkward." McSteamy, in all his glory... SO glad he's back.

Hmmm...I interpreted his blame taking as being for failing at trying to rebuild his marriage with her like he'd promised to try to do, and then ultimately destroying any possibility there by sleeping with Meredith, which personally, I was behind him doing for those reasons...even if their marriage falling apart was actually due to shared blame overall...

And yeah...

's McSteamy's attitude at seeing him in there with Addison...just classic...

The fact that Derek stuck around afterward and started to drink up was fitting as well imo...and a counterpoint to how he reacted to finding Mark with Addison the first time around...

lancer1993 · 09-25-2006, 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ele309 (View Post)

Jeez, my secret is out!

But sorry Craig, you're too young for me. I don't wanna go to prison.

I'm not that young!

As for GA, we can we talk about ep 2? next week when it airs in the US?

Labyrith · 09-25-2006, 08:34 PM

i haven't seen the second episode yet but you guys are getting me SO EXCITED!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Robotica · 09-25-2006, 09:23 PM

Quote:

As for GA, we can we talk about ep 2? next week when it airs in the US?

Honestly, as far as I'm concerned at this stage you can talk about it around the boards already if you like, whether you've seen it or not. I just request that for those people who are choosing to remain spoiler free (difficult as that may be this week given the unusual circumstances), you all continue to use the spoiler boxes until after it's original scheduled air date on Thursday...

***Johnnie*** · 09-26-2006, 02:29 AM

Some pics from the episode... [From the first 15 min anyway]

http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/2025/30201jd9.jpg
http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/6605/30202ea1.jpg

iloveyou_iloveyounot · 09-26-2006, 10:30 AM

did you say that episode 2 is already on you tube robotica? could you private message me the link to that?

bobbins34 · 09-26-2006, 12:20 PM

I loved this episode!

The Bailey/Izzie scene was very emotional....such great acting.
Burke/Christina storyline with the parents was great...loved the father reassuring Christina at the end
Addison drunk was great
Also loved Callie caught out dancing by the Chief

And lastly...the twist with Addison in the hotel room...classic!

Ingrid16 · 09-26-2006, 12:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iloveyou_iloveyounot (View Post)

did you say that episode 2 is already on you tube robotica? could you private message me the link to that?

YouTube removed the clips of 3x02, because they were posted "without Disney's permission"....

Mio · 09-26-2006, 04:44 PM

Spoiler:

Robotica · 09-26-2006, 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iloveyou_iloveyounot (View Post)

did you say that episode 2 is already on you tube robotica? could you private message me the link to that?

I would, but apparently they've taken it down already...

You could always try the LJ Grey's episode community, or try seeing it anyone else uploaded it at You Tube today...

Best of luck...


Fan Forum > Archived Television Shows > Grey's Anatomy > Episode 3.02 Episode Discussion ~ I Am a Tree