Survivor #10: Edge of Extinction ~ Is the 3rd time the charm for Joe?
 

Bringing my last post over from the last thread:

TFTNT! Love the title. :P

I’m kind of split on whether or not I like the castaways not knowing about the twist. On the one hand, it feels kind of unfair because they don’t even know enough to be playing with that in mind. But on the other hand, it was kind of cool to see Reem walk up to those signs after being voted out and be surprised by the opportunity.

do you think each person will be isolated? that would be interesting and maybe people would quit lol.

I’d rather they not be isolated, because I’d love to see some strategy emerge on Extinction Island, and I feel like we’d only see that if people can interact. Plus, I feel like keeping them in the group is the only way to do it because they still have two tribes in the game to devote airtime to.

do you think they will all get to stay and then do one challenge after the merge to get back in, or do you think they will do a challenge every time someone new comes in and the loser goes home?

I do wonder how it’s all going to play out... :shrug:

If they do one challenge as people get voted out, then it’s just Redemption Island all over again. So I don’t think it will play out like that.

Yeah, April. I agree. I don't think it will be like that.

maybe they ill do one every 4 people or something? also very similar tho.

That could be, as well. :nod:

2nd episode was a bit slow for me. :shrug:

I was hoping Kelly would actually go home. No luck. I kinda liked Keith, he seemed like a nice guy. Too bad he got taken out but am I surprised? Of course not....

Still waiting to find out if he will be joining the other chick...

I was hoping Kelley would get voted off, too. While I don’t dislike her, I can’t say I’m like the biggest fan of her.

So far I think David is playing the best out of the returners. I like his alliance with the newscaster/Koolaid man.

Joe didn’t even have a confessional tonight. :( But he was still Joey Amazing in the challenge.

The editing of the Aubry segment was kind of funny. :lol: I know she said she doesn’t like kumbaya Survivor, but I’d much prefer to be on a tribe like that that can have some fun and dance around and stuff.

Although I was really hoping we’d make it two whole episodes without anyone finding an idol, good on Lauren for spotting it. (Complaint, though: Seriously, idols used to be hidden, there were clues required to find them, etc. This was literally a blue thing in a log, so it really stood out.) Anyway, I’m open to Lauren as a player, and on a shallow note, I think she has an awesome, healthy body.

I kind of don’t mind Wendy.

Keith getting the votes is fine. I didn’t have an attachment to him. Great editing for a cliffhanger at the end. I would expect him to go to Extinction Island, though. I’m still open-minded about that twist. I do think the lack of knowledge players have about it makes it harder to endure.

I dont like her. lol. She just comes off so know it all and she has no social skills imo. She comes off super cold and calculated.

I too like David and am rooting for him.

Audrey annoys me. But I am totally with her in not being into the whole Kumbaya thing... no thank you. That was giving me cringeeeeeeee vibes. But I too would just pretend and play along lol.

I dont mind Joe but we haven't seen much of him.

I dont like Wendy, she is playing too hard imo.

I wonder if David is going to benefit from being the only two time player (as opposed to three time) among the returnees.

I get that some of these newbies are saying, “They already had their shot. A newbie needs to win.” But come on, realistically, if any of them makes a big enough splash on the season to warrant getting invited back for a second go round, of course they’d jump at the opportunity!