ShadowhunterღReader

Shipper List

1. warangel88
2. goodbreakingbad
3. AlwaysCB
4. hlgreenie
5. KeepThisaSecret
6. Honeycutt
7. B.Chambers
8. Queen of Babble
9. HaylijahღEndgame
10. murphyboy11
11. HunterX
12. Chastidy
13. sagittarius13
14. Gwenny39VD
15. Ron_Cullen
16. Boringblog
17. Charlone
18. -Fated to Love-
19. green eyes sparkle
20. *Stephie*
21. Sweetgirl465
22. Stlavin95
23. we are not alone
24. IBelieveInMiracles

Previous Threads:
01 - http://www.fanforum.com/f394/roy-har...lice-63086688/
02- http://www.fanforum.com/f394/abercro...21-a-63105152/
03 -
04 -

x

Against_all_odds

ttftnt!

Charlone

TFTNT

Any thoughts about the last scene?

Against_all_odds

I want to cry-Oliver will feel the betrayal more than anyone else if it's true. He's misplaced his faith in people before,but Roy was in/still is in love with Thea.

Charlone

I agree. I don't want to accept it, really, I'd prefer Malcolm to be her muderer.

You can't kill me!

I don't believe it. Why would he kill Sara?!! Makes no sense...

Charlone

It doesn't make sense. I have the feeling it's just a dream and the writers want us to keep our focus away of the actual Sara's killer. Although, it may be pretty obvious that he dreamed it for some reason. We'll see it on the next episode. That last scene opened a new plot for the next episode.
We know Roy. He never wanted to hurt someone who is innocent, he always showed his desires of saving lives. If the writers want to make him a bad guy, I'd feel it very forced because they never showed Roy having bad intentions . Even Sara was very surprised when she saw her future murderer, and I don't think that she'd be that surprised if this person was Roy. I mean, her reaction would have been different.

DigificWriter

The promo for next week's episode doesn't make it sound like it's anything other than real. The question is, what are the circumstances surrounding it?

You can't kill me!

I won't believe it until I see it. I don't think I could stomach Roy being the one that killed Sara (no matter the circumstances). Roy is one of the two biggest reasons I watch this show.. I don't even want to think about it.

Charlone

Writers play with our minds and reactions after something surprising happens, though Roy was acting weird all the time, there aren't enough reasonable ideas for make me think he was her killer. I thought that they'd keep with the plot of "who is Sara's murderer?" until the last episode of this season and I still believe it, so for me it's pretty soon for them to give us the name of her killer.

You can't kill me!

I don't mind the writers playing their game... I just don't want it to ruin Roy. Obviously something is going on.. but him being Sara's killer?? Just no. I don't want it.

Charlone

I agree. I would feel like all his dreams of saving people were for nothing. The fact he could be Sara's killer would not complement so well with his beliefs .

DigificWriter

The writers wouldn't have telegraphed' something like this whole Roy issue if it's not headed somewhere specific and is just a 'red herring'. I don't know what the writers' "endgame" is, but there's more to this story than it just being a 'dream'.

Charlone

If there's more of this story based on his dream, it doesn't necessarily have to be something about Sara's death.

DigificWriter

A writer isn't going to 'telegraph' something this significant if it's just a 'red herring'. What they revealed tonight is the equivalent of "sticking a gun on the wall and calling attention to it". Said "gun" is going to have to be "fired before the end of Act 2".