LH-C

Confusion is a majorly extreme understatement...

At least it didn't suck Big huge love for the SPN crew!

angelface211

It was the best thing ever. I am so happy and sad at the same time! I don't know what to think but I do know that every single one of those actors rocked it! Jared's perfomance especially when he was fighting Lucifier from the inside it was brilliant!
there is so much to talk about now I know we will be busy all summer but i just don't know how to survive.
Dean's devotion to Sam was by far the best part. i knew they cared for each other and would die for each other but what Dean did in this episode was beyond everything! He would show up just to die so Sam wouldn't die alone.
Its depressing but I loved it.
So is Chuck god?
And at the end is that Sam or is that Lucifier?

LH-C

I have 2 questions -

1) Either God was masquerading as Chuck OR Chuck was taken up to Heaven.
2) Is that Sammy OR Lucifer OR..........Michael?

angelface211

Hmm Michael didn't think of that one.

I don't know about Chuck being taken to heaven I thought that but I don't know he seemed all more cleaned up in the end totally different from the Chuck we've seen all the times before. i think hes god.

I don't know it didn't seem like Lucifier but then its just to easy for it to be Sam

LH-C

OK now we need a stickied HELLATUS thread. I can't wait 4 freaking long months

Anique

I only just stopped bawling.
God it was so amazing.
a real ode to the brothers this was.

And that's just Sam. I really do believe that.
That streetlight was just crappy and old.

LH-C

Ahhhhh....Now people are speculating that Sammy is a damn ghost?!?

I didn't get to cry or sing along to the songs or anything, because I ended up watching it with my dumb dad. Never again, I totally freaking swear.

Anique

naaah not a ghost. you have to make some kind of decision to be a ghost right?
and Lucifer... no I don't think so. The writers said over and over that the Apocalypse would be wrapped up at the end of the season.
Demon? hmmmm. this might just be wishful thinking but I really don't think he's been in Hell long enough for that.

naturellebella

I bawled for the last 5-6 mins of the show straight. STRAIGHT!

I was thinking he came back as Michael because that prison is only suppose to hold Lucifer, not Michael so maybe Michael used Sam as a way to get back up to Earth.

Anique

I think there were only 7 minutes of ep in total during which i wasn't crying.
I like that theory too. Michael better give Sam back straight away then though, just sayin.

angelface211

I cried so much an episode hasnt made me cry this much since AHBL. I dont believe that Sam is a ghost that just doesnt make sense to me and I hope that Kripke wouldnt do that. And as for him being Lucifier I dont want to believe that either because of what Kripke saying about this storyline being done and over with. I guess its just wishful thinking for him to just be Sam that would be too easy and nothing in Supernatural is ever that easy everything has to have a price

sunny214

I agree with your whole post angelface!!!

And here is my take on the finale.

OH MY GOD! OH MY GOD! OH MY GOD!

I have watch it and it left me totally confused and messed up and frustated and angry and although really what an great episode and Jared totally rocked this episode.
So does Jensen and all the others.

Sorry but I write it down just the way it pops up in my head. Because I am not really thinking straight right now.

I love Dean in it - he was the big protective brother at his best. He didn´t give up at Sammy at all. Even when Bobby and Castiel did (which broke my heart).

And Sam and Deans talk in the car about leaving Sammy in the cage was so beautiful done and acted and broke my heart, too.

At the end I was only screaming at my screen.

NOT CASTIEL - NO NO NO NO!!!
NOT BOBBY - NOT HIM TOO!!! YOU CAN´T DO THAT!

And when Dean kneeled on the grass at the end and was only by himself and so broken - it broke the tiny little pieces which were my heart in even tinier one.

Love Chuck! I don´t know but maybe he is really god!

And then Sammy I couldn´t have loved him more and couldn´t feel more sorry for him then then. And Jared was beyond words - his scenes with the mirror - brilliant - and his scenes at the end with coming back to Sam. I can´t describe how much I love him in this episode!!!!
And that last look is driving me crazing - because I don´t know how to read it.

It could be disappointment of seeing Dean so happy or
it could be disappointment for being back on the living hell
it could be disappointment because he thinks that Dean brought him back with something
it could be disappointment in himself for the things he has done to be back

it could be that it isn´t him it is Lucifer or Michael!!!

I just don´t know and that is killing me for sure.

I am glad that all of them survive at the end and that the love between the brothers really saved the world.

My first reaction to the Lisa/Dean scene was WTF!!! And I was screaming at my screen again. That I soooo hate this. And that I don´t like Lisa at all and what they are thinking by bringing her back again. But after watching it again - I saw something different in it.
Dean is almost dead inside and sooo broken it is unrepairable. But he promised Sam to try to live a apple pie life. And maybe this peaceful life with a woman which clearly loves him and gives him the much need comfort (which neither Castiel or Bobby can offer) helps him a little bit to stay alive.

And Jensen was amazing in this scene when he gives in in the hug from Lisa his face is so full of emotion and you can read in how much pain Dean is - it is absolutely brilliant, too.

LH-C

I don't know who or what is in Sam's body, but it's going to be damn complicated getting Sammy back to normal at the beginning of S6.

Season 6 - Woah...I still can't believe that it's going to happen. Yet, now I'm becoming worried that it will suck, just like how X-Files started sucking after their Season 5.

Anique

I'm just gonna live on my pink cloud and keep believing that is just Sam.
They paid their price. over and over they paid it.
And they passed their test. Doesn't God reward those who pass tests?
Because I personally don't think the guys who saved the world deserve to be in hell. Sam in real hell and Dean in living hell. and don't tell me he was happy because he was not. The lamp could have flickered because of the magic it took God to poof Sam there.
No, they passed their tests, paid their price and now they get their reward. The only thing pissing me off is the fact that I have to wait until September to actually see them reunite.

sunny214

I came up with another theory about Sam and his look at the end.

Maybe he was in heaven after they jump in the cage.
Maybe God rescued him and put Luci back in the cage and pulled Sam out of it.
Like in Buffy at the end of season five when she sacrifices herself, everyone was thinking that she went to hell but she was in heaven.
And when she was "rescued" from it she was empty in side and not happy to be back.
Maybe the same happened to Sam and he is not happy to be brought back.
Or maybe I am just out of my mind crazy with that thought.


I like the idea of Sam being Dean guarding angel now on that matter. Maybe he really was rewarded Anique . God knows that Sam is happy when he is with his brother and maybe he sends him back as an angel to look out for Dean.