Roxi9

I don't know if it's Peyton, but I'm sure it's NOT Shelly. She would never do that after her 'thing' with Mouth. Plus she didn't see the tape and Brooke knows about her abortion (and was nice to her).

Katiesocks

Hmmm Peyton said they were never friends?

BrownEyes1980

I didn't notice it cracked in that sentence. I did notice that it cracked in the "You are one to talk! You are one to talk Peyton!!!" and "Here is a picture of you and Lucas on my birthday!!" sentences though.

JLBrooke

How can Peyton be stupid enough to say this? Talk about putting herself in the spotlight, huh?
I guess she's not that bright...

And all this starts to explain why Brooke throws eggs... I just wish she could tell Peyton about the BN happening when NP were broken up. I want to see the stupid girl's jaw drop...

Casey1010

Peyton walked right into that one


That scene is going to be great. When Brooke throws the mug and right when she says " never meant anything to you" gets me everytime. Sophia owns scenes like that. I would love like a whole scene of Brooke just yelling at Peyton . Maybe her voice would break a little , her eyes would tear up. I would die.

BrownEyes1980

I guess so. According to the BP clip she did at some point. My guess would be she probably said it at the party before or after the punch. We’ll probably see it in one of the flashback scenes.

And yes Peyton is actually this stupid. I cant believe she actually says that! I guess she has a 10 second memory or something. It definitely looks to me that this Peyton is feeling like what she did isn't as bad now that Brooke apparently screwed Nate. Stupid I tell you!

JLBrooke

One should always be careful with the stone-throwing in a glasshouse The blonde girl seem to have a real goldfish-memory... first she forgets about asking Jake to marry her and goes straight home to confess her love for Lucas... then we have all the times when she told Brooke that she would NEVER do anything to hurt her... If i remember correctly it all started with: "Trust Lucas, trust ME, trust yourself Brooke"
Hmm... Yea, that worked out well...
And now this, choosing to forget the TWO times she went behind Brooke's back.
God, can anyone say DORY?!?!?!?!

Meluffy

wait i'm lost...what is happening with the "lucas defends brooke over peyton" spoiler????

JLBrooke

Hi Mel

i'm a little lost too but i guess it was an off-camera thing...

SimplyB

Crap are you serious that the BL scene is off camera?! I mean is it that serious that we can't get a freakin BL scene.

Casey1010

I don't think Mark would give us B/l scenes back to back like that So you know, if we got the one in 4.16 we absolutly cannot get another in 4.15.

Meluffy

ok so we don't see that scene..i'm not surprised actually! damn mark!

but luke really defends brooke, doesn't he???

and hey Lynn, how r u?

JLBrooke

I'm starting to think that even the BL-scene in 4.16 will be like a 2 second-thing in the background. Mark seems to be determined not to have Brooke and Lucas talking for the entire season...

Casey1010

I think your right Lynn , which is BS but should we expect anything less?

Meluffy

mark is a **** !!!

seriously wth is wrong with him??? an entire season with less than 2 minutes BL scenes! that's smart to keep his fans...no wonder why the ratings r so good!