LGC

As you wish

3 points - #15 - It was funny, but nothing came from it
2 points - #40 - I don't think I have to explain why
1 point - #7 - I need a third choice

nlpnlp

Yeah, don't change it. It's great!

My votes:

First two picks stayed the same, hence the same reasons.

#17 – 3 votes – Alicia being nervous for no reason.
#18 – 2 votes – I loved Will offered to meet the kids, Chicago's 16th most eligable bachelor was offering to meet someone's kids was a huge step but of course we all know how that ended.
#15 – 1 vote – Let's eliminate Celeste. Supporting Rony on this one.

You sure don't like his sisters.

Gelfling

Thanks for the thread I love the title

rony3369

hi-
voting aside for a moment, what do you think A's lowest point was regarding W this season?

p.s
thanks for the support regarding sceane 15

EndlessღLove

Awww, you don't have to thank me, I love talking about H and S so much Let me know if you watch the finale ! I want to read your thoughts about it


Current Tally

#15 - 15
#40 - 5
#7 - 4
#36 - 3
#17 - 3
#18 - 3
#9 - 2
#46 - 1

People who voted: Sophia, Eug, rony, Aga, T, Mariana

LGC

Hard question! The most annoying moment for me was knowing that she considered Will a distraction, because imo it was nothing like it. It was contradictory the bursting into tears when you finish something that is a distraction or a toy. But then there were much more situations from this season when she was there for him or care about him if you want!

Limbo bimbo

3 points: # scene 18 - Alicia was pretty much oblivious to Will's feelings!
2 points: # scene 22 - The look between them was very fleeting. Not as loaded as usual!
1 point: # scene 25 - Sorry for those who like A's "I'm gonna miss you," but all I retained from this scene is Will's teary stare, the way he kissed her shoulder, and folded her in his arms instead of giving vent to frustrated rage, which is what he should have done.


As to A's "lowest point" regarding Will, it was when she claimed she didn't love him in such a calm and definite tone she broke my heart with her words.

EndlessღLove

Current Tally

#15 - 15
#40 - 5
#7 - 4
#36 - 3
#17 - 3
#18 - 6
#9 - 2
#22 - 2
#46 - 1
#25 - 1

People who voted: Sophia, Eug, rony, Aga, T, Mariana, Semia

THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS I will marry this post ^
Tbh, I think Alicia wants to believe that he was a distraction. As someone said in the past, can't remember who, regarding Alicia and Owen's conversation about her not loving Will and Owen saying it would be very complicated, if you are afraid to get hurt it means there are feelings involved.

Aga_darkside

I generally didn't like the way Alicia behaved during the affair, at the beginning I was okay with her attitude and I understood it. But all the time I waited for even a little change... And then she just went and ended it all It was not I had in mind after S2 finale, basically nothing after first 3-4 eps.

EndlessღLove

She acted cold and distant, my heart totally broke when Will told her "I am not interested in anyone else" and she was like "Will, I don't want to talk about it". I mean, nooooo Will was pretty much giving her his heart
As I said, I think she wanted to convince herself it was just sex. Will wanted to commit but it was too much for her. She is still married after all ! I hope they fix this next season.

Gelfling

Hey ladies

We are celebrating 200,000 posts on the board! Come drop by the thread to help us build our "Things we learned from TGW" list

Alexa

i just finished episode 2x10. SIGH. alicia telling will that he was right, that the convo they needed to have was about diane... FRUSTRATING. i want them to talk about that damn voicemail!

but, her hearing the tape for the first time was she was so affected by it!



these two kill me.

does anyone have links to any good will/alicia icons?

EndlessღLove

Told you, S2 is the season of angst We were so frustrated about the voicemail thing too.
I don't want to spoil you but you need to watch Episode 14 asap !

She was ! Poor baby

Welcome to the club


Try here : The Good Wife

And Chellie makes great icons too but I can't remember the link of her website.

rony3369

one of As lowest point imo. even if you dont feel the same way he is your friend- act like it! there are so many other things you can say/ act like in a situation like this. even if its to talk about how its really nice to know but youre not there yet or whatever..
i think what i realy dont like about A this season is that she was ( i think) so afraid of the "thing" she had with W, that sometimes she didnt act as a friend to him

Neth_DK

My votes:

3 points: #7 - Still the same reason. = I don't really understand (the forerunner of) this scene. Yes I understand that they were trying to make it seem like Alicia was jealous of Celeste in the previous scene with the mediator, and that Will in this scene is praising her for her effort, but maybe it's because I'm watching without subtitles (I actually don't think so), but I don't really see any jealousy in this previous scene. And by the way this scene was quite short and with the exception of the remark in the caption this scene was only about work.
2 point: #11 - Also still the same reason. = Even though the remark "loosing what I love now..." could mean Alicia, I really don't think this was what he meant. Actually I have difficulty seeing how he could mean Alicia, because wouldn't it actually be an advantage to their relationship if he took another job, as he as consequence wouldn't be her boss anymore? This leads to that I think that this scene isn't really an AW scene and is mostly about work.
1 point: #13 - I really don't knew what to choose, as there is (in my opinion) about a handful scenes left which are not quite (or nearly) as good as the rest, but as I have to choose something I chose this scene because I think it's too short.