Rookie Blue - Break up Buddies [Andy McNally & Nick Collins]#2: "For what it's worth, I was totally on Team McCollins" - Dov - Page 3

LifeGivesUSigns · 08-01-2014, 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElenaBelle (View Post)

Tftnt. Love the title

I was satisfied. They've shared scenes during the season without any tension so I thought they were back to being on good terms since they've been working together. They haven't shared a lot of screen time but there was a scene earlier in the season, I can't remember which episode, but he was giving her some advice and it was very friendly and comfortable. Andy seemed really surprised when he brought up unresolved issues so I think this was mainly to give us closure.

Was it Duncan advice?

Yeah, I guess this was an attempt to give us closure. I just wish more had been said, especially on Andy's part.

But hey, hopefully they can at least share some scenes as friends in the future because I did enjoy their friendship scenes in s4.

ElenaBelle · 08-01-2014, 11:41 AM

Yes, the Duncan advice. It felt like a scene from before they started dating. They were very comfortable. If Nick is going to be in another relationship it would probably be a good idea to give him closure.

I also hope now that they're good again we still get plenty of scenes. I need more singing in the car

LifeGivesUSigns · 08-01-2014, 11:44 AM

Yeah, I would like to see some singing on Nick's side this time

hmmm I'm still wondering what makes Orange Food Girl's role so "mysterious" ... probably just my Grey's Anatomy brain thinking, but maybe she's someone's long lost half sister?

Andy's?

McQueenFanGirl · 08-02-2014, 07:06 AM

Nice return to a Nick and Andy dynamic this last episode. I liked all their moments, even the awkward ones. It was in character for Nick to be okay because Andy was happy. It reminded me of last season when Sam tried to do the same. But unlike Nick, he added that he couldn't be around her because he wasn't the one making her happy.

I mean the show is so easily poking holes in Andy's choice of men, it's almost comical. Nick was the better choice, she chose wrongly. Nick may not be with her, but he wants to be in her life.

Ugh. Marlo is back, so I guess we'll have insecure Andy RME. I swear if the show manges to do a triangle with those three, and couldn't with Nick/Andy/Sam, I'll be very irritated. All I ask is for more Nick and Andy scenes next season.

Source

LifeGivesUSigns · 08-02-2014, 07:26 AM

Thanks for the gifs

I do want them to continue to have scenes as friends

I'm not sure what they will do with Marlo to create drama for A/S but am kind of glad Nick seems to be staying away from that mess and veering into his own storyline with OFG.

(I actually thought they did a decent job of showing Andy's conflict in 5x03, but then they just dropped and ignored it, which is irritating.... so much potential wasted)

ladybugjess · 08-02-2014, 10:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LifeGivesUSigns (View Post)

(I actually thought they did a decent job of showing Andy's conflict in 5x03, but then they just dropped and ignored it, which is irritating.... so much potential wasted)

Yeah. I think it would have been interesting.

IndigoEyes · 08-02-2014, 11:15 AM

those gifs are great! Thank you! I hope that after all the crap, Andy is finally becoming secure in Sam's feelings for her, and Marlo will be a NON-issue. Andy should realize that he never had the feelings for Marlo that he did for her...he's not gonna screw that up by doing something stupid with Marlo

LifeGivesUSigns · 08-02-2014, 10:18 PM

Does anyone here watch The Bachelorette? (don't judge me

) I caught the finale the other day and that show's Andi and Nick had a breakup even worse than our A/N

Sooo awkward. lol

la villanelle · 08-03-2014, 06:04 AM

omg, if she's Andy's long lost sister I'll die!

IndigoEyes · 08-03-2014, 10:58 AM

that would be weird

ElenaBelle · 08-03-2014, 11:17 AM

That would be too daytime soap opera for the show

Love those gifs

IndigoEyes · 08-03-2014, 11:44 AM

it would definitely be too "Grey's Anatomy"

LifeGivesUSigns · 08-03-2014, 03:00 PM

Haha I'm curious how the role is mysterious though ... Unless they just said that to mislead. Meredith has had about three long lost sisters on Grey's, so it's time for Andy to have one

She actually has a parental situation very similar to Meredith's ...

IndigoEyes · 08-03-2014, 04:12 PM

Please...no more long lost anythings! I'd be ok if she's just a random stranger with no ties to anyone - no deep dark secrets, no bipolar disorders, no big issues that need to be resolved..just a cute girl with an orange food fetish that Nick can fall for. But of course, that would not be dramatic enough

Forwood4Bamon · 08-03-2014, 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by McQueenFanGirl (View Post)

Nice return to a Nick and Andy dynamic this last episode. I liked all their moments, even the awkward ones. It was in character for Nick to be okay because Andy was happy. It reminded me of last season when Sam tried to do the same. But unlike Nick, he added that he couldn't be around her because he wasn't the one making her happy.

I mean the show is so easily poking holes in Andy's choice of men, it's almost comical. Nick was the better choice, she chose wrongly. Nick may not be with her, but he wants to be in her life.

Ugh. Marlo is back, so I guess we'll have insecure Andy RME. I swear if the show manges to do a triangle with those three, and couldn't with Nick/Andy/Sam, I'll be very irritated. All I ask is for more Nick and Andy scenes next season.

Source


Fan Forum > Archived Television Shows > Rookie Blue > Break up Buddies [Andy McNally & Nick Collins]#2: "For what it's worth, I was totally on Team McCollins" - Dov