the only other sherlock i've seen is BBC sherlock, but i love how different one this is :love:

I saw one episode of the BBC series but, couldn't get into it. I remember reading a Sherlock mystery story when I was in high school.

That could either be a very good or very bad idea. :lol:

I have never seen the BBC one but everyone seems to think it is great so I might give it a go when I have a chance, I really like Martin freeman but I somehow can't see him being a better Watson than Lucy, But then again I have mostly only seen his comedy roles

i love it :thud: it was really the only 'sherlcok' thing i've ever liked in a long time :lol:

I don't like that otter-looking guy, so I can't see myself getting into the BBC Sherlock. :lol:

I think I'll stick with Elementary, since I already love the cast and dynamic.

I've watched Sherlock BBC and loved it. Martin plays Watson very well, imo. His Watson is quite different from Lucy's of course but not less interesting and likable.

i might give it a go soon :) there aren't very many episodes so it won't take me long to watch it!

I'm finding it hard watching Watson in every scene at the moment without thinking where she got her clothes from. I'm in love with her fashion

i def recommend BBC sherlock... it's great, i mean i LOVE elementary, but i also love bbc sherlock, what's great is how different they are :love:

does anyone have any title suggestions for this thread? I am not very good at thinking of them :lol:


awesome :) thanks for the recommendation!

She has great clothes. :nod:

Add me please :)

I remember watching Lucy on Ally McBeal, she hasn't aged at all!

Because their wouldn't be a better fitting female Watson?

that title sounds great!