MadisonNorthFan

^ I wasn't because the episode title gave it away, and when there''s no body the character's usually not dead.

Alexa

the ending was a bit shocking. i didnt think sutton was dead, but i didnt think shed be back anytime soon.

alec is still weird, i wonder whats up with him.

same with justin... breaking up with laurel was so mean! i know he is hiding something, and i'm starting to get curious. but he still gives me the creeps.

paper rings

Yeah me too.

fox24

Well I was spoiled that Sutton wasen't dead, but I am suprised she came back this soon, I am also curious to know Justin secret

Sixon_Love

I was also spoiled so I knew sutton wasen't dead but I also thought she would come back after a few episodes but not in last nights episode so that was a shock.

Thayers story about liking sutton since 2nd grade was cute.I can't help but still like them.

My heart broke for Laurel when Justin broke up with her.The actresses did a good job in those scenes and I really want to know what Justins secret is

ABCFamilyTV

Sutton’s return was definitely a shock to me! How do you think that is going to play out next episode? Do you think it was Sutton playing a lying game or could Annie Hobbs really be behind it all? And as far as Justin is concerned….what a jerk! I know he is hiding a lot of secrets but he was awful to Laurel! I was surprised that she didn’t give him back the bracelet at the country club but was glad she didn’t because he probably would have wound up destroying it along with all the rest of his mystery box. Did anyone get a good look at that autopsy report? I wonder what it said….

paper rings

I think she is playing a "Lying Game" and I want to know Justin's secret.

fox24

I still like Thayer and Sutton to.

Alexa

I felt terrible for Laurel. I kinda went through something similar, where the guy ended things without a clear reason... so i felt her pain. Stupid Justin. I mean, it was obvious he didnt really want to break up with her, but he had to for some reason...

i still like thayer and sutton as well, i loved when he said he had a crush on her for so long.

paper rings

Me too, but Justin is hiding something...

Simon Spier

This show just keeps getting better and better!

Always & Forever

I agree!

Sutton coming back was a complete shock to me! And I knew Thayer recognized the wrapping of the gift and thought it could be from Sutton. I still like them together, too. His story about liking her since the 2nd grade was so cute! I honestly think that this show can only get better and more intriguing from here! They keep adding all these new mysteries that just keep sucking you in!

paper rings

I don't who I like Sutton with together.

Alexa

gah, thayer is so cute! wish sutton could see it and get over ethan already.

i dont think shes lying abut annie/the accident, but her saying shes different? yeah right.

also, whatever happened to eduardo?

i felt so bad for emma at the end there, but its almost a relief.

jessie09

yeah she's not different. and someone may have tried breaking in the house but she was already dressed for the party so she probably was gonna go to the party anyway.

yeah i think shes gotten used to them while pretending to be sutton but i think she's relieved she doesn't have to pretend anymore.

does anyone think that maybe annie hobbs isn't the birthmother?