[ollibear]

Welcome to the 3rd Bay and Toby Appreciation Thread

Credit: Slayerfan714

Supporters:

1) jessec12
2) MaybeLove.
3) girlyshorty85
4) Kiss of Death
5) Queen of Babble
6) julyhsm
7) Maité
8) s e r e n i t y
9) MagnoliaFairy
10) MPFan09
11) Sincerely, Me.
12) Stay to the Lights
13) xlennie
14) americanamuchacha020
15) forever yours
16) jules166
17) Pippa Plum
18) Elena_1716
19) Grhmlz
20) Slayerfan714
21) Moonauthor
22) Wingster
23) EyesOnFire
24) *Lizzie*
25) Anastasia Belle_02
26) ~TwilighterTee~

Credit: Slayerfan714


Previous Threads:

Bay & Toby Thread #1: Because even though they're not biologically related, they'll always be brother and sister

http://www.fanforum.com/f376/bay-toby-thread-2-because-cant-keep-kennish-down-%2Ahigh-five%2A-63073907/"] Bay & Toby Thread #2: Because "Can't Keep A Kennish Down!" *High-Five*

[~AnastasiaGrey~]

Thanks for the new thread

[ollibear]

Originally Posted by ~TwilighterTee~ (View Post) Thanks for the new thread

When I created the thread last month, I removed my name as a supporter. I don't dislike either character. Their relationship has lost its magic for me, though.

All through Season 1, I loved Bay and Toby's sibling relationship. Even during Season 2, when Toby set up some boundaries with Bay, in order for his relationship with Nikki to thrive, I still supported Bay and Toby.

I accepted that they had almost nothing to do with each other in Season 3. I didn't like it, but I accepted it. At least, they had that one beautiful scene where they made the light show, on the side of a wall.

I had high hopes for Bay and Toby in Season 4. But then, Toby forgave Daphne for her transgression against Bay so quickly. Daphne allowing Bay to take the fall for her is unforgivable to me. For Toby to let it go that quickly is unthinkable.

We should still see signs that Toby does not trust Daphne, because how do you trust someone who does something like that?

And Bay feeling Toby and Lily should abort their baby was a sad turn of events for Bay and Toby's sibling relationship, too. I almost always like Bay better than Daphne, but that is one time that I liked Daphne better. Bay doesn't know Toby, if she thinks abortion is the best decision for him. He got teary-eyed looking at Lana's ultrasound in Season 2, and that wasn't even his baby.

Bay and Regina may have the "baby chip" missing, but Toby loves babies.

So the Bay and Toby magic died for me, at least, for the time being. Maybe it will return in Season 5. I miss their old banter and obvious closeness.

[Okun]

Well, I only know S3 and already like their connection. But from what I´m reading here, I think I maybe should go back to S1 & S2 instead of moving forward to S4 after I´m through with S3.

[ollibear]

Originally Posted by Okun (View Post) Well, I only know S3 and already like their connection. But from what I´m reading here, I think I maybe should go back to S1 & S2 instead of moving forward to S4 after I´m through with S3.

Bay & Toby are AWESOME in Season 1.

[~AnastasiaGrey~]

Originally Posted by Okun (View Post) Well, I only know S3 and already like their connection. But from what I´m reading here, I think I maybe should go back to S1 & S2 instead of moving forward to S4 after I´m through with S3.

Yeah I agree with you?

[ollibear]

Originally Posted by Okun (View Post) Well, I only know S3 and already like their connection. But from what I´m reading here, I think I maybe should go back to S1 & S2 instead of moving forward to S4 after I´m through with S3.

Did you go back to Season 1 and 2? Or did you keep going into Season 4?

[~AnastasiaGrey~]

Originally Posted by ollibear (View Post) Did you go back to Season 1 and 2? Or did you keep going into Season 4?

Season 4 had its ups and downs too

[ollibear]

Originally Posted by ~TwilighterTee~ (View Post) Season 4 had its ups and downs too

Yeah.

[~AnastasiaGrey~]

[ollibear]

Now that Toby is guaranteed a big story because of his son with Down Syndrome, I hope he grows closer to both Bay and Daphne.

I want to see lots of Toby and Bay scenes this season. I'm hoping we see all three of the siblings doing everything together like the three musketeers.

[~AnastasiaGrey~]

Originally Posted by ollibear (View Post) Now that Toby is guaranteed a big story because of his son with Down Syndrome, I hope he grows closer to both Bay and Daphne. I want to see lots of Toby and Bay scenes this season. I'm hoping we see all three of the siblings doing everything together like the three musketeers.

Yeah I would like to see that

[ollibear]

Originally Posted by ~TwilighterTee~ (View Post) Yeah I would like to see that

Maybe we will see a first birthday party for Carlton! That could be really cute! Bay could start doing some of those sweet things for Carlton that she told him she would do, before he was even born.

[ollibear]

Bay and Toby need to rebuild their relationship in Season 5. Toby sort of stuck his foot in his mouth by telling Lily everything about the Bay and Tank situation, and even though Bay didn't hold a grudge over it, in fact, she said she was glad that Lily had spoken up for her at the college, it still didn't do any favors for Toby and Bay's sibling relationship.

Plus, Bay wasn't in favor of Toby and Lily keeping their baby at first, so that made things strained. Then, Toby didn't tell Bay that he and Lily were moving to England.

Bay and Toby's closeness has taken a big hit ever since Toby met Nikki. I miss Bay and Toby being close.

[~AnastasiaGrey~]

Originally Posted by ollibear (View Post) Maybe we will see a first birthday party for Carlton! That could be really cute! Bay could start doing some of those sweet things for Carlton that she told him she would do, before he was even born.

I would love to see that