barneyrocks

They really were. I didnt understand Rosalie in BD at all. How all of sudden, she was on the same side with Bella.
Then again, nothing made sense in that stupid book.

Sorry for the tiny rant.

Pure.Magic

Ranting is good for the soul, and inevitable when talking about BD.

And I agree, Rose was reduced to a one-dimensional, desperate, pathetic childless bitch in that book.

barneyrocks

Alright then.

~ayumi~

I sadly agree

Soleya

That's a shame though, i hate when SM ruins her own characters.

~ayumi~

Everybody was very out of character in that book. Sometimes I even think another person wrote it Either that, or SM's memory was erased.

Pure.Magic

The thing is that BD was a sequel to Twilight, and it mightve made more sense had it followed the first book, but after NM and Eclipse, and all teh character development we saw in those books, BD was just all kinds of WRONG.

Soleya

Oh yeah I've heard that, it should've come after Twilight. Yeah if those two books in between had never happened then I'm sure it would've been perfect.

change my luck

IA, I think she so desperately wanted to write a baby in the series that she came out with that and it was just all wrong. She went back on pertty much everything she had written.

Soleya

Really, so it was all so that they could have that baby? Weeeeird.

kostilicious

aww I love Rose.. she's soo pretty..

Soleya

She is very pretty! And smart too.

madness

She should've stopped after Eclipse and let us imagine that she dumped that weirdo sparkling vampire and went to the hot & handsome werewolf.

Soleya

I agree, she should've stopped.

TayKris

I agree. Eclipse should have been the last book in the series! That's all. There really was no need to go on, especially the way Meyer did it. She could have stopped at Eclipse and been fine. It's more fun to leave the ending up to the reader's interpretation anyways.