Chrissy

The whole will they won't they with Kara and Lee is really annyoing me...

The more I think about it, the more I like the idea that Gaeta is a cylon just because he is the normal guy.
I can easily picture a dozen more Gaetas all over the fleet living the quit live.

Alexander

I've been saying it for over a year now, that Felix Gaeta maybe one of the final five b/c we don't know much about his past. Before that, I had a feeling that Galen Tyrol was too, but it's unlikely now that he is.

Here is the thing, when D'Anna was looking and said "I'm sorry I was so mean to you"...it had to refer to someone who was maybe down on new caprica for those 4 months of occupation, maybe they "jailed that person", or whatever and D'Anna interrogated him/her? Something to think about.

The Crow

I never thought Chief or Callie could be because they had a kid. There has been a really big deal made about Helo/Sharon's daughter, so it seems like the writers wouldn't introduce another Cylon baby this quickly.

migamoo

Her being sorry works with my theory that maybe it's Anders. Back on Caprica, she was going to kill him in Downloaded but Six and Boomer stopped her by killing her.

Chrissy

Hmmmm, that's true.

Subject

I still say Tigh is one of the final 5. Anders is a good guess but she only tried to kill him which wouldn't really mean much if he is a final 5. On New Caprica Anders was free or at least somewhat. However, Tigh was tortured, held captive, ect.. She had much more to be sorry to him for.

Alexander

Ashley and Mike...both very good theories on who D'Anna was talking about.

So possible candidates:

Sam Anders
Saul Tigh
Felix Gaeta

GEORGEIII

Yep. I would agree that most probably one these is in fact a cylon, otherwise the D'Anna comment "Forgive me, I had no idea" doesn't make any sense. I guess the comment works for Baltar too, but I agree that development would be far too easy and obvious to prove correct.

Roslin?

yossarin

Has Lucy Lawless's character been written out of the show??

Did anyone notice the BSG reference on the latest Veronica Mars from this week? I thought it was really random like most of their pop culture referennces

migamoo

Lucy was contracted for a certain amount of episodes, and she's fulfilled that contract. Will she be back again, who knows.

Chrissy

I hope Lucy is comming back, she was a so wonderful ruthless character.

Subject

I think we can rule her out because of the fact she had cancer and needed the Cylon blood to cure her. Of course, maybe that blood is changing her dna and turning her into a hybrid?

migamoo

I don't think Hera's blood would do anything. I'd just take that for what it was, a blood transfusion.

Alexander

No, Rosilyn can't be a cylon, or she wouldn't have had cancer.

Lucy Lawless will be back, but she has done the 11 episodes she was contracted to do for S3.

Subject

It's good to hear that she will return.