[Gone]

And what are your favorite seasons?

[rossfangirl86]

Originally Posted by stlavin95 (View Post) I personally would have put S1 on top and had S5 much lower, but I did mostly agree with it. You?

s1 would've been at the top for me, for sure. s4 would've been second then s3. Not sure about the others since I liked the seasons mostly for LP and nothing else.

[stlavin95]

Originally Posted by rossfangirl86 (View Post) s1 would've been at the top for me, for sure. s4 would've been second then s3. Not sure about the others since I liked the seasons mostly for LP and nothing else.

Assuming S2 and 5 would have been on the bottom

Originally Posted by Gone (View Post) And what are your favorite seasons?

S1, 4, 3, 6, 5, 2

[Gone]

Originally Posted by stlavin95 (View Post) Assuming S2 and 5 would have been on the bottom

I agree about the fifth and second season

[stlavin95]

Originally Posted by Gone (View Post) I agree about the fifth and second season

Neither season was that great

[Gone]

I agree completely

[stlavin95]

Season 5 would have been much higher if LP and NH's storylines were better.

[Gone]

Yes, in the fifth season I was a little puzzled by Luke in relation to Peyton.

[stlavin95]

Luke was pretty OOC that season, that's for sure

[Gone]

Aha. He was like a pain in the ass.

[stlavin95]

He really was

[rossfangirl86]

My biggest problem with s5 is how Lucas was written. Even though there were times I disagreed with him in previous seasons, he really upset me in s5. And he treated Peyton in a way I never expected and it hurt to see that. I understood him being hurt and feeling lost without Peyton but the writers took it too far. Lucas had put himself to the side to be there for Peyton in previous seasons so it was definitely OOC for him to act the way he did in most of his scenes. The writers wanted to keep things concealed and in the process, we lost Lucas' pov until the end of the season. And Sam, I could only rate s1-s6 but yes s2 and s5 would be at the bottom of my list for sure. Not just because of LP but because of the seasons overall.

[stlavin95]

That's definitely true and trying to do another triangle just didn't work at all.

[Gone]

Yes, this triangle was not to anything

[stlavin95]

There was no point to it at all.