Sandy0401

It really wasn't.

BlondieLeigh

So much loss.

Sandy0401

^And from such a young age too. I mean if we really thought about it and dug deep they lost Paige from adoption, their mom to death, their dad walked out, than Grams and so on and so forth. I mean while not loosing Paige per say or even in Phoebe's case remembering Patty their might've been some emptyness or odd feeling-especially when they learned they could call upon their mom, Grams, learned of the sister and so on and so forth.

BlondieLeigh

I feel like Prue at least must have at least wondered when it comes to Paige. I just can't see her 100% accepting "Mommy got a little fat.", especially with her being a little older.

Sandy0401

^I always assumed Prue would have known. There's no way. She's smart and she would have seen Patty pregnant with Piper and Phoebe too.

BlondieLeigh

I think she must have had some idea. Like, even if she wrote it off because she didn't believe they would ever keep it from her, she'd still have wondered.

Sandy0401

Exactly.

runawaaay

I think Prue noticed too. I mean she's a smart girl. But they did say that Grams casted spell on them to make them forget about things

Sandy0401

^Ahh I wouldn't be surprised if that's what had happened. Also stating that it makes no sense that neither Patty nor Penny would've admitted that and been honest about it too.

BlondieLeigh

Yeah.

Shame we never got to see Prue find out. She'd have been livid!

Butterfly85

Ha, that's true. She would of been pissed if they were lied to their whole lives about having a sister they never knew about lol.

Sandy0401

^She'd be beyond pissed. She's so protective of Piper and Phoebe imagine her learning of Paige.

BlondieLeigh

Could have been some explosive scenes if we saw her find out.

Sandy0401

^I think Shannen would’ve killed those scenes and throw in Finola and Rose and I think it would’ve been amazing scenes

BlondieLeigh

They would have been epic.