Gracie

he could be.

I've been a fan of Lindsey since GL and probably before then, but yeah she was awesome and she and Joy did have great chemistry.

othobsessed

Oh, great thread idea!

I for one miss Thomas Ian Griffin (Peyton s1!Dad). I always felt he was much more loving to Peyton and had better chemistry w/ Hil, but maybe that's just me.

I also love Huey Lewis and Bess Armstrong- sucks that because they're so good, its hard to get them back.

And IA Mel, Lindsey McKeon was awesome as Taylor. I may not have liked her character all that much, but she was an awesome guest star and had great chemistry with Joy.

Oh, and Sheryl Lee! Awesome.

Xbel

Peyton's Season 1 Dad was a different one than in the other seasons? (have only seen clips of OTH)

othobsessed

Yep he was. *sigh* I was really pissed that they changed the dad cus I absolutely adored Thomas Ian Griffin. He was on OTH for 2 episodes, if I remember correctly. He was great- but I guess they couldn't get him to come back third season. So they changed him. The other actor isn't bad at all, but the way he interacted with Peyton seemed more condescending IMO.

Xbel

Weird. Couldn't they get the first dad back because he was filming movies? Was her dad only in so few episodes then?

now.it.all.begins

I think Peyton's Dad #1 was in more than 2 eps...maybe 3. But yeah I liked him better than Larry #2 too. My fav guest stars would be Gigi, Lydia and Jimmy, Larry #1, and Derek #2. Lindsay did have good chemistry with Joy but the whole backstory she had with Nathan creeped me out.

Reni^

Hey Sweetie!
Your posts always rock me,but that one is just awsome :
btw any Psycho!Derek fans here?

now.it.all.begins

Oh and I forgot to mention that I loved Ellie too. I liked Psycho!Derek...at least until we knew he was Psycho!Derek.

naturellebella

my favorite guest star is tyler hilton! i didn't like him at first cause yes effecting naley but i always thought he was hot and funny cause he speaks of himself in the third person! CHRIS KELLER WORK IS DONE HERE! yes yes he helped in the end. and in real life he seems so down to earth.

Uncle Cooper is pretty cool too. too bad he ran away.

now.it.all.begins

I loved HUC! Yeah it seems that I love a lot of the guest stars. I hated Chris Keller in S2, but in S3 I loved him b/c he was just so funny "Stop hitting me!" "Stop kissing my wife!".

othobsessed

Guh. TYLER! I can't believe I forgot about him, I feel ashamed. Its been a long time since he was on screen.

Well s1!Larry was introduced in episode 11, when Lucas goes all kamakazi-rakeboy on him. And then in episode 12, we see him on webcam. =) Do we ever see him again?

Matt Barr was great as psycho!Derek, although he became very creepy once Derek became psycho.

now.it.all.begins

He was in episode 17, the cheerleading competition, and in episode 18, the boy toy episode. So I guess that makes it 4 episodes then.

iTzMeCaNdi

I really liked Chris Keller, he was just tooo funny. I also liked Ellie alot. Okay, I pretty much liked all the guest stars!

Xbel

He died, didn't he?

naturellebella

Season 3 Chris is the best! "chris keller was dog paddling just fine on his own" "CHRIS KELLER WAS DROWING JUST FINE!" yes yes nathan chris interaction is best. and he's all like road trip nate ROAD TRIP!