Welcome to the Conspiracy Theorists (JLs) #172



Welcome to the appreciation thread, started by gottaluvlafferty, for James Lafferty and Bethany Joy Lenz, who as you know, play Nathan Scott and Haley James Scott, the on-screen married couple of One Tree Hill. Chemistry definitely flares on-screen but hey, what about off? There has been speculation that the JLs are dating in real life. Of course both claim to be single but we know how they like to be covert . Plus you never know what goes on behind the camera's...look at Chad and Sophia. So this thread is for those that believe that *something* is going on with these two. Our name "Conspiracy Theorists" was created by Vilandra-N-Kivar Lover aka Whitney and us CTs will continue speculating until these two just admit it already




The JLs' Fact and Rumors
A collection of evidence to support our theories and/or that gets us started on new ones
1.) In teen people James "wouldn't say if he's single." This is presumeably around the time that he and his girlfriend from Hemet broke up. Sources say she was jealous of Joie. He is now admittedly single. At least from her.
2.) When Joy was on the Menu the thing on the side said: "Bethany is rumored to be dating her One Tree Hill costar (and on screen boyfriend) James Lafferty in real life!"
3.) There are rumors that James broke up with his girlfriend because he liked someone else. If it's true we know who..
4.) Total rumor, we don't know where this came from, I was reading in a web site and they were talking to James and they asked who is he most close to and he said, "Joie, is like my best girl-friend." They were asking if he ever would date her and he said "HELL YEAH, I WOULD DATE HER, WE HANG OUT ALL THE TIME AND HAVE FUN BUT MY GIRLFRIEND GETS IN THE WAY," he said laughing.
5.) James was asking Joie on set what to get for lunch and she answered, "Just get whatever you know what I like!"
6.) Apparently she’s teaching him guitar and said "he's getting pretty good" on TRL.
7.) They’ve been spotted going into van's and/or trailers together, even when they have to change wardrobe's..TWICE!
8.) At TRL it was so obvious, he was pissed he didn’t remember what soap she'd been on and she knew his birthplace like that *Snaps fingers* and they mouthed things to each other and Sophia/Chad looked at James like, "You should've known that!"
9.) They stand next to each other at TRL and for pics and he is always staring at her on TRL. Also, in their second time at TRL she grazed his arm when she didn’t have to. Yeah, TRL is our biggest evidence.
10.) She said in J -14 "I love him to death and think he's awesome" and this after admitting they don’t have much in common,neither do NH, and she said "It's funny we have nothing in common and I’m married to him!" (we need to get the exact quote) So she inverted b/w fiction and reality, but we already know those lines have been crossed.
11.) James stalled before saying "I’m alone." on TRL as if he was thinking "I'm not alone but we're hiding our relationship so don’t say anything."
12.) On the DVD she knows an awful lot about what’s in and not in his house, so we assume she's been there a lot which means they hang out off-set and not just to get lunch. She goes to his house and she was the only one who knew how unfurnished his house was.
13.) Also, on the DVD she says he owes her honey. Heehee that could have so many meanings
14.) When Chad on the DVD says NH got married for the sex he tells her to "defend the character" which means James likes NH. We're pretty sure he's into Joie, too.
15.) Again on the DVD, she mentions how perhaps she may have been crying before taping a scene in TGTPU because her eyes look tired. Everyone comments besides James, who is oddly quiet. Hmm...could the lovely JLs have had a fight? Well, we know they made up.
16.) Again on the DVDs when she says her hair looks good, he laughs the loudest. We know he agrees.
17.) And again on the DVDs, the whole cast support NH and better yet S/H, especially, cheer like crazy when the JLs get all hott and heavy! Could this be because they know whats REALLY going on?
18.) Amber are very lucky SPY reported this "Ok, yesterday during filming Joie was back, now I didnt see her alone we had this outside scene and I look around and I see James and Joie walking around the corner together and I could have sworn that I saw his arm around her. So that made my day right there, but that is not the end, at lunch I got off the van and I saw James and then when I was waiting in line I saw Joie, James was waiting for Joie to get in the van that was soooooo cute!! And then the best part we had a scene and she couldnt do the scene without James she said "I'm sorry I cant do this intimate of a converstation with some one who isnt James" and then becasue I saw her calling someone and to my surprise it was none other than Baby James I heard the convo, and she said "Will you do this for me?" and they did the scene together! it was soooo sweet!"
19.) In CosmoGirl Magazine Joie says she's reading A Brave New World for the summer....James's favorite book is A Brave New World!
20) They were in New York at the same time... hmmm...
21) On Celebrity Tastemaker James comments on Joie's song on the OTH Soundtrack. He loves his girl's voice. "Joie actually has a song on there that's really good..."
22)8/16/05 - Today I saw James and Joie. And lets just say whenever I and I stress I saw them both they were at eachothersides. No necssialry talking to one another. Even tho they were talking in between takes, during one scene. But during a scene with just Haley it was really hot out today so during after the scene(between takes) she went over and sat in the her chair and her chair was right next to James's and he was getting makeup touchups....and Joie sat down and put her hand on his shoulder but he couldnt move. It was like for 5 secs but I saw it!!! And then she put up her hair cuz it was tooo damn hot today.

Random: ->"It was up to James and Joy and in many ways, it still is."
Written by Mark Schwahn a.k.a A Closet Conspiracy Theorist



Shippers

If anyone wishes to be added to the list, please PM Lindsey_JL23

History/Theory behind the Watch
The reason behind the newfound obsession for THE WATCH came about because Mel (mystic2182) always asked for pictures of it over on James' thread. Coming over to the CT thread, the discussion turned to everyone's love for THE WATCH. It was noticed that James wore it both on-set and off-set... and someone mentioned the possibility that James received it as a gift from his girlfriend Joie... thus a monster was born...

Obsessors of THE WATCH*



1. mystic2182 (Mel)
2. KaLiPinAy23 (Lyn)
3. pinkpretzel (Elise)
4. welshygirlyUK (Tasha)
5. abby-anne
6. gottaluvlafferty (Tiffani)
7. katinthehat (Kat)
8. adamsartangel
9. JLsNHLuver23 (Carly)
10. BabyJamesIsMine (Jackie)
11. naleyrocks23 (Anna)
12. takenforaride (Katie)
13. .:AmandaScott:.
14. OneTreeHillQT (Kim)
15. .:Farah:.
16. Lindsey_JL23
17. Callalily
18. OtHlUvR23 (Jess)
19. Naleyfan004eva (Mackenzie)
20. luvjls23 (Sam)
21. Sarah's Twin (Marcie)
22. Heather23 (Heather)
23. Immortal CandyGirl
24. somewhereelse
25. othlov3r23 (roxy)
26. mela23
27. sweetbabyj
28. shellyw9
29. MLMluvsOTH
30. kudo04
31. ~Anna~
32. aprillynn
33. TiNA 23
34. bEbE xVi
35. Eisberg
36. James_is_my_baby23(lauren)
37. Nathan4Haley
38. TaRhEeLPrInCeSs08
39. OTHPsycho23
40. Konstantine23
41. nadini (Nadikins)
42. sexyjames!! (Lauren)
43. JLs~PriNCess (Ella)
44. naleyscott4ever
45. Tutor_Girl (Nicky)

*THE WATCH Supporters' Name is credited to Mel.
The OFFICIAL Watch banner is credited to luvjls23.

Check Out the first edition of the JL Gazette!
(Thanks to Trish, Mela, and April for this lovely creation!)



The Great Package credited to Mela







Paul: "I loved shooting this scene. haha Both these people are two of my best friends on the show. James Lafferty bought a house, we call it the One Tree Hill Triangle in Wilmington, NC where we shoot, because Chad, and I and James have a house within 4 blocks of each other. And that is Bethany Joy Lenz, and as you know she has an incredible voice and is an incredible singer. And this took 3 or 4 attempts because we came up early and saw more than we were bargaining for. We had to do that one a couple of times. As they say, the package was exposed. So we had to go back and time our cameras a little bit better. And they were both such good sports in that scene. And I think it's a fun scene."



It's a shame they didn't put those 3-4 outakes in the EXTRA FEATURES.

Title by ME. Mwhawhaw!

__________________

__________________

__________________

"Stay with me? Always."
Katniss♥Peeta

Icon: DrankofSnapple

__________________

__________________

__________________

__________________

__________________

__________________

__________________