season 3 was amazing but the BL parts did ruin it just a tiny bit for me. however the writing was just so good and the group interactions and storylines were phenomenal. 316 is my favorite episode.
but season 1 was the original man. i just get such a warm feeling when i watch that season. i cant get over the small town feel and the start of the relationships and the nathan/lucas rivalry and the basketball... just GUHHHHH. my heart.