I have a whole CS playlist that I listen to while reading Tumblr at night.
My #1 pick would probably be Your Arms Feel Like Home by 3 Doors Down. The bolded especially gives me CS feels.
I think I've walked to close to love and now I'm falling in
I felt so many things this weary soul can't take
Maybe you just caught me by surprise
The first time that I looked into your eyes
And there's a life inside of me that I can feel again
It's the only thing that takes me where I've never been
I don't care if I lost everything that I have known
It don't matter where I lay my head tonight
Your arms feel like home, feel like home
This life ain't the fairy tale we both thought it would be
But I can see your smiling face as it's staring back at me
And I know we both see these changes now
I know we both understand somehow
There's a life inside of me that I can feel again
It's the only thing that takes me where I've never been
I don't care if I lost everything that I have known
It don't matter where I lay my head tonight
Your arms feel like home, they feel like home to me
(Hold on, you're home to me, just hold on, you're home me)
Others in my top 5 CS songs would be:
All That I'm Asking For by Lifehouse
A Twist in My Story by Secondhand Serenade
Hopeful Heart by Jason Walker
All We Are by One Republic