Awesome topic!
I really love Anne/Gilbert too
I also love the Love stories series like the boy next door
and this is my very favorite book, The day I met him.
Here's a summary
Lilly Cameron is having a great time cruising around town in her father's car - until she crashes. When Charlie Roark arrives with his tow truck, they hate each other. But they quickly realize they need one another: he'll fix the car for free if she'll pretend to be his girlfriend.