OMG that's EXACTLY what I thought when I first saw the pilot! I admit, her likeness to Tracy (I think that was the character's name? ) made me think she was gonna be annoying, and that whole gold-star thing certainly didn't help her case at the time. But as the episode progressed and Rachel had that real talk with Finn and Will, I started warming up to her. Plus, the girl can SING.

And Finn's pretty cool too. I'm guessing Rachel and Finn might be the couple that everyone wants together but doesn't actually get together until late. Who knows. Hopefully the show will prove me wrong.