I think we were being optimistic with our betting. I'm changing my bet for June
Here's the current updated list:
Disney,
Reality TV, Cartoons,
Doctor Who, Moonlight,
Pushing Daisies
John Krasinski, Private Practice, Justin Timberlake, Smallville
Ian Somerhalder, Ashley Tisdale, Lost, Greek
Johnny Depp, Leighton Meester, Rachel Bilson, Chuck,
Tom Welling, Scrubs, Carrie Underwood, Hayden Panettiere
Blake Lively, Criminal Minds, James Lafferty, Degrassi
Emily Deschanel, High School Musical, Adam Brody
Heath Ledger, Star Wars, Third Watch, Big Brother
Star Trek, Skins, Ed Westwick, Joan of Arcadia
Penn Badgley, Milo Ventimiglia,
How I Met Your Mother, Young Americans
Disney's customization thread has been opened in October 2007... I'm not sure I can wait that long for this board to get some colors
ETA: Updated the list!