I have to say I agree with Steph. Only have a select few awards are more special and prestigious. And I don't think awards are the only thing to judge an actor, those things depend on so many variables. Like who decides on to whom the award is given. If it's the fans (say the MTV movie award), the result will certainly be different than what it is if the critics decide. And awards aren't the only thing or even the main thing to measure an actor's fame or succes or talent. There are many actors out there who never got for example an Oscar but are without a doubt one of the best, for example Leonardo DiCaprio.
And to be honest, I highly doubt either Hayden or Natalie care about who got more awards. I don't think they give a damn about which one is more popular or famous. If they still keep in touch, I'm sure they talk about totally different things.
