yeah, thats the thing with me. I don't want her to give up mortality just for her to be with Edward....he is perfectly fine with her growing old and living an actual life, but oh no she has to be immortal. The only concern I have with that is what Edward has been saying all along something along the lines of you losing your Human interest/experiences...well what if after she becomes a vampire the love she feels for edward now as a human isn't there when she is a vampire?
that would make all it be a waste, and then no one would be happy.
and out of curiosity who do you ship in HP?