I heard they didn't want her for 36 because of Johnny. I don't know if it's true, but people were making it sound like Johnny didn't want her (and Paulie) around, and that's why.
I just feel like both Cara and Paulie like the Challenge in general too much to just "be done". If they're done, I don't think it was entirely their choice...I think production doesn't necessarily want them anymore so they're gonna pretend they are done like it was their choice.
Thanks