broken crown

Made by Ms_Melika

Alright, post your Season 4 speculation and theories here! Remember, no actual spoilers are allowed in this thread...just your personal theories and speculation!

Starfield_Scribe

Well can we establish the "contenders"? I can't remember who was where anymore...

Astra

Well I'm not sure... I am wondering if it's Will (JJ's guy).... but I'm still mulling it all over

Brooke08

i think JJ but she just loses the baby and will gets killed? its a way of letting AJ have the baby over hiatus and killing the storyline when she come back to work.....ie) time off for the baby while JJ recovers then poof no baby?

neel luvs tony

But Will never got into the SUV

I still think it's Hotch

broken crown

But then why would they have gone through the whole trouble of writing her pregnancy in? They could have just hid it and then handled it differently.

Starfield_Scribe

Yeah that's what I was about to say

neel luvs tony

I agree. Besides it's in a way character development. Why mess with that? People in law enforcement do have kids, they don't have to be all miserable lonely and without kids.

broken crown

Right exactly. What kind of message would that send if they just offed her kid like that? Not a very good one.

Kiane

I can see that scenario. Or Will is killed. JJ is injured. JJ still keeps her baby.
Or JJ loses her baby, and they end her and Will, because he wanted her to leave the force in her condition. Anyway it could accomodate AJ's maternity leave.

In the long run, it does not matter where there were all located, the TPTB will write in what they think is dramatic to them.

broken crown

^ I agree with this.

Starfield_Scribe

What I meant by where they were is which characters were getting into cars I don't remember how many of them were...

Cris

Just a guess, of course, but I have a feeling it's Hotch. I think that would change the dynamics of the BAU the most (as much as I hate the idea).
I don't think it's JJ because her pregnancy storyline would have no purpose after all. Two episodes pregnant to lose the baby like that...

Melissa Ann

I love the idea for this thread! Thanks for starting it!

I'm going to repost my theory from another thread:

REPOST:
I have a feeling that the person that got blown up might have been JJ. Just because she is pregnant, and her boyfriend/fiance basically said I quit my job for you and our baby. So for the show dynamic and her storyline, it would be so traumatic for her to be the one to get hurt and loose the baby.

This is not a spoiler, just my thoughts/opinions on the subject.

Thanks for the article scan. It's going to be a mystery until the season premiere I think, they've been very tight lipped about story lines and where they might go.

Plus both Penelope and Reid have had events in the past that left them in danger, when Reid was kidnapped by guest star James Van Der Beek and when Penelope was shot, so that's my reason for excluding them as possibly being the ones in the car to blow up.

Prentiss was sort of in a situation when she went into that house to capture that guy that was torturing women, she had a scare there.

I'm sort of going through a process of elimination in a sense to come to my conclusions, it's making my brain spin with wondering who it is, and who set up the bomb to begin with!!!

If there is any more news on this subject, I hope they give us something to chew on you know.

broken crown

I just don't think they'd write in her pregnancy. only to have her lose it. I mean what was the point?

Besides if she were to lose the baby in a trauma like that, she might quit the BAU.