fox24

Well rumple and hook both have views of Milah. hook remembers her as this adventures women and Rumple as selfish.
Plus Milah was taken from Hook in a abrupt manner it's why I was angry at Gold the most in 4.08 he hit Hook biggest trigger

I don't believe rumple wishes he was still with Milah he mocked Hook mourning of her in 4.08

I also think Hook has made piece with Milah death and his au is Liam

Austenphile

However when we were in the EF, the "villains" won when Regina cast the curse and the "heroes" lost which is the main reason I have never bought Regina's theory about the book. She had won when it ended.

ETA I think Josh might also be talking about Emma's disappearance as well as her going dark.

T'Lynn

THIS!

Seriously. The way the book ended the villains did win ....

fox24

Yep that's true

wild sage growing

She had "won" when the book ended, but that wasn't the end of the story.

I agree on Josh's comments.

Take_my_Revolution

I'm going to with hold judgment of JMO's dark costume until I get a better picture. She looks really angry and kind of over the top.

Idk if we will have Milah in the AU. I think that Hook will be Lt. Jones not a pirate in the AU. That is my prediction. I want to see all of their costumes.

Belleislove

I don't think there's any reason to believe Milah would be the AU. It would be hideous thing to do to us, lol.

No promo pictures yet?

wild sage growing

Sadly, no!

I wonder what the hold up is...

Belleislove

They're trying to make us cry?

CityGal

That's my best guess, too.

It's whether or not they remember their SB-selves that concerns me.

T'Lynn

If Rumple is the one getting the author to make sure all the villains get happy endings how does Hook fit into that? He was a villain... I can't see Rumple making sure he gets his happy ending, even if it was just as a result of him being a villain and being lumped into that.

Ahhhh ... I'm going crazy trying to speculate but nothing is making much sense!

Koda

Take_my_Revolution

Maybe it isn't Rumple who changes everything? If it's Rumple, then most likely Hook is dead in his AU. Besides, I don't see the writers excluding Colin from the AU. I'm going to say that Regina and/or Henry are the catalyst for this change.

Hook is the wild card. He calls himself a villain, but he is clearly sided with the heroes. To me, it seems strange to have Hook and Rumple be good guys in the AU, when Rumple is clearly a villain this arc and Hook has been on the hero's side. I just want Lt. Jones only because I want the goofy ponytail.

I also want Charming to wear the Prince James outfit for this episode because I am shallow.

wild sage growing

This episode hurts already.

Whyyyyyyy do we do this to ourselves?!

Koda

I have no idea, I'm still trying to wrap my heard around it that this episode already sounds like it'll be even more painful than the last one, which... I seriously didn't think was even possible?