MysteryXX

That was kindly said

Arrakis

A total mess.

Heda_Khaleesi

yup

James26

Alycia says that there are parallels between this relationship and Madison/Alicia, but I didn't see much of the Madison/Alicia bond, so I wouldn't know.

Movies

I actually liked Madison/Alicia very much.

SongIceFire

Just when their relationship started to get in the centre, Madison died

Movies

Same goes for Alicia and Nick I think.

SongIceFire

Could you have imagined Alicia/Nick/Charlie as siblings?

Movies

Totally, Nick and Alicia could've be her older siblings. I wished Charlie wouldn't have killed Nick, that he was still alive and they could have become a little family. But that's not FTWD

Heda_Khaleesi

interesting point actually. but then again this would have been a complete different storyline.

Movies

Yeah, maybe I would have liked that better though. Well not maybe, I know I would have liked that much better.

Heda_Khaleesi

would have been too peaceful though. but i wished Nick was still alive.

plot twist: would you guys (and especially James26 since he/she seems to be the biggest Alicia/Charlie fan of us ) have preferred/liked if Alicia was in Nick's place and Charlie killed Alicia, and Charlie had bonded with Nick? would Nick have killed her or would he have forgiven her?

James26

I didn't know the character well enough to say. I do think that he should have exited differently, but in a way that would have still created tension between A/C, leading to the bond that they have now -- whatever that bond is.

Heda_Khaleesi

i somehow think Nick wouldn't have forgiven Charlie easily if she had killed Alicia for example. i think Nick would have killed her or - probably more likely - just left the group and went on a journey himself.

SongIceFire

^ I have the same feeling. I don't think Nick would have killed her but he wouldn't have forgiven her. And him running off his own sounds like something he would do.