ocfan27

American Nightmare
November 3rd 2016
The CW

Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) investigate a case that leads them to a devout religious family that lives off the grid. The brothers realize that the parents are hiding a huge secret that could destroy them all. Meanwhile, Dean struggles to accept Mary’s (guest star Samantha Smith) latest decision.

Written by: Davy Perez
Directed by: John Showalter

ocfan27

I lowkey miss Sam’s psychic abilities…ugh why did they have to show that scene again! Never forgiving Mary for what she did! Omg!! This is straight up crazy!! Sam and Dean as priests! I missed that disguise…happy to have it back!! Give it up Dean…Mary isn’t worth it. Dean doesn’t want to talk about his feelings…but he really is hurting! Here is goes with the whipping again! A new twist in the case! Yes with the sweaters!! well that sounds suspicious!! And the person on the motorcycle…creepy! These people are definitely shady for sure! Sam confronting the mother…amazing acting in that scene!! Sam and Dean on different pages for the case! So the daughter is alive? Maybe? The mom thinking the daughter is responsible for what happed…getting crazy! The EMF meter love when Sam uses it!! Sam hiding! Dean going to confront Beth…it probably won’t end well. She didn’t want the job? On the phone and Sam telling Dean that she’s alive! Watch out Sam!! See…that’s why you don’t split up!! I would always trust Sam…no matter what!! She is psychic too…Sam trying to connect with her on that level. Sam doesn’t see her as a bad person! She’s poisoning them all to get to heaven…just another day on Supernatural. The mom is definitely the devil! The mom deserves to be taken away! The daughter was definitely not a bad person! Sam is such a great person! I love him so much!! that was a cute text though…even though I hate what Mary did! Omg! Ok what?? Great episode…felt like an early one!

Tennessee Whiskey

Thanks Lauren.

I'll edit the OP in

magikhands1

Thanks Lauren & Bee My days are so mixed up that I didn't realize today was Thurs *smack forehead* off to watch it

ocfan27

Welcome! Thanks for fixing the OP!!

Verbal Warning

I liked the ep but it was a bit slow, didn't we have something with stigmata before? it did have that old school SPN fell that I love Ugh....Mary still not feeling her for leaving the boys like that, it has cause mixed emotions between them.

Liia

I liked this episode, definitely the best this season... Probably because we finally got a Sam/Dean episode, no Mary around, just the boys solving a case I liked the story and the way Dean apologized to Sam at the end. I also enjoyed their bantering about Vince

magikhands1

I really liked this episode. Okay, I'll admit that I loved how much Sam was it in You know me, such a Sam girl But I also loved the way we saw once more how different the boys' minds work. Dean was sure it was Beth (right name?) and Sam was positive it was a ghost. Both wrong, & once again Sam gets hit over the head and wakes up in a compromising situation. But it was interesting to see how he handled the girl, trying to help her. Knowing what it was like to have powers. Too bad he doesn't have them any more. Or maybe he just hadn't tried to. Kind of wish he would have

But I'm really not liking the way the British MoL are tailing them Nope. She would have been fine, yet they stick their noses in it where it doesn't belong. Go back to your own country. Sorry, not liking this arc at all.

GoSpikey

(Added the 'supernatural' tag because the one that's there now says 'superatural'.)

Loved this episode, and was devastated the Brits couldn't let that girl live. She would have been fine, and I would love to have seen her return later on, to check in on her.

Tennessee Whiskey

^ Thanks. I'm pretty sure not many people are searching for Superatural. Typo's

Liia

IKR? I liked Magda, she would have been absolutely all right

Tennessee Whiskey

I wonder if this will lead to Sam getting his powers back? That's twice this season they've mentioned them.

Liia

^ That would be interesting to see

Tennessee Whiskey

I'd like to see his powers back. Not the demon blood ones but the other ones.

Batman66

Anyone find her completely unsympathetic? I mean she did cause the entire mess over a phone.