stlavin95

He definitely liked Haley and Brooke too

Cristofle

He...did, but man, those two could go AWHILE without having a meaningful scene. LOL. Even long after Peyton was gone. He clearly wasn't AS invested.

stlavin95

True, still liked them more than Peyton and Haley though, lol

Cristofle

LMAO, man, Mark dropped them so hard they went all the way through the basement.

stlavin95

Still gotta know what happened there, since it appeared he liked them a lot in S1 and even S2.

Cristofle

It was really weird. He just...stopped writing for them. It certainly wasn't Joie or Hilarie causing an issue, they always got along.

stlavin95

Wonder if they will ever come up on the podcast?

Cristofle

It might, because at some point they just basically stop sharing scenes except for casually. I remember it was actually weird when Haley was like "I call godmother". Lady...you two barely hang out. LOL.

stlavin95

Interested to see if their comments will be on Peyton's reaction to Haley coming back in S3 will be as well

Cristofle

That was also kind of weird? Gah. OTH could be so weird.

stlavin95

Made no sense, considering she was really supportive in S2.

Cristofle

I was watching old GL clips of Joie last week and man...she really had a superior screen partner back then. LOL. Sometimes it's hard to go from that to watching OTH.

stlavin95

Not hard to be a better screen partner than James, lol

Cristofle

Paul Anthony Stewart is just so...alive compared to James. LOL. He's so dynamic. He and Joie clearly adlibbed with each other a lot and it made the scenes seem very natural. I've gone from one to the other before, like straight from GL to a OTH clip, and it's weird. And a letdown.

stlavin95

I think I remember Joy admitting it took years for James to feel comfortable doing that in their scenes