What if game #1... what would happen if...
 

:wave:

Saw this game on another board and it looked like fun! Basically you ask a "what if" question on the show and the next poster answers their theory. Then they get to post a question! Sound good? :look:

I'll start:

What if Big never went to Paris to get Carrie?

Great idea Danielle! Oh god i dont want to imagine that scenario but i think Carrie would have returned to New York and would probably have just settled into single life again or maybe even approached Big seeing as how she was thinking about him :look:

What if Miranda never became pregnant?

She would still be with Robert.

What if Charlotte used her first divorce lawyer?

She would still be single

What if Carrie and Big never had an affair?

He still would have gotten divorced from Natasha

What if Anthony and Stanford hooked up?

They would have a firey and passionate relationship :lol:

What if Charlotte and Trey had children?

it would had been a bigger mess because trey isn't good for her

what if samantha never had cancer?

Her and Smith may not have grown closer

What if the show wasn't set in New York?

it would lose it's fifth character and would feel less exciting

What if Carrie married Aiden?

she would've worn her wedding band on the chain round her neck

What if Natasha had never come back from the Hamptons early and caught Carrie in the apartment?

Big would've gave in and told her about Carrie.

What if Charlotte never became Jewish?

She would still be searching for happiness.


What if Carrie and Natasha had been best friends?

Carrie would never have had the affair with Big


What if Aiden and Carrie did not break up?

Carrie may have had another affair with Big

What if Carrie never mentioned the 'scrunchie' to Berger?

Carrie and Berger would've lasted a teeny, tiny bit longer. They were a mess from the get-go and the scrunchie was just straw that broke the camels back.

What if Big and Samantha had hooked up in the pilot episode after she made a pass at him?