shoots up a flare

same old story

I have a lot of thoughts about tonight's episode, but the biggest ones are;

01) Joy is amazing.
02) I could not have hated those Jamie/Nathan scenes more. Rage.
03) Nobody cares about Skills/Lauren/Mouth.
04) Grubbs was annoying tonight.
05) Why are you still alive, Chase?
06) I commend OTH for not really mentioning the STD tonight.
07) This Katie ish is the most ridic thing in the world.
08) Julian was so harsh on Alex in that scene. So, because she slept with someone, she's a horrible person? Please.
09) Thank God Haley wasn't pregnant. DNW another pregnancy storyline, or another Jamie.
10) TAYLOR JAMES. Where for art thou? Haley/Quinn scenes continue to be awkward and made of fail.

qwerty101

Am I the only one who thought it was bit weird how Brooke suddenly started crying when Haley mention kids. I know it's an upsetting situation, it was still a bit strange to me though.

Those Miranda/Grubbs scenes were annoying, the proposal was stupid though I do like both characters.

Felt really bad for Haley at the end, her grief is overwhelming her and she's too strong to share it with anyone else.

Katie= Loony bitch is loony.

I really liked that Brooke finally let go of her insecurities concerning Alex/Julian. Glad Julian is going to do his best to protect her.

same old story

It wasn't strange to me, because it's not like she just mentioned kids, she was all "Zomg, gotta have kids, they make life worth living, they carry ish on when parents die, etc." It would have been weird if she had done it if Haley had just been all "Jamie helps, I love my kid" or something. Did she even really cry? I thought she just looked really sad, and maybe got teary eyes? Idk, I was distracted by Haley's fugly shirt, ngl.

Beautiful Blur

Okay show, still waiting for you to tell me when I should give a damn about Grubbs, Miranda, Chase, Lauren, Mouth, and Skills. *twiddling fingers*

qwerty101

LOL, yeah you're right I was just a bit surprised that Brooke chose to mention it then since I thought she already told Haley that she couldn't have kids.

same old story

Nah, she just told Haley she wasn't preggers. Though, I did mean to say that it was strange because that scene/subject was so random, since it was dropped forever ago. I'm assuming they only brought it up because it was supposed to relate to the Haley pregnancy thing in this episode, which was random enough as it was, since I forgot all about it after that commercial break, even though I was spoiled for it going in.

LoVeJunkie

Hmm Brooke calling Julian boyfriend and then him saying something along the lines of I'm glad your calling me boyfriend again. Now why does that seem familiar? And than Alex going "you're always savingg me." K show I know you suck now but reliving your glory days with new pairings is NOT going to help. This show makes me mad

-Katie-

Wow. Anyone else find it pathetic that Grubbs, Miranda, Chase, Skills, Mouth, Lauren, Alex and weird lead actor had more screen time than Haley?! It's so pathetic where this show has gone. The Brooke/Haley should have been longer and maybe more focused on Haley - even though I'm glad Brooke finally told her, but I felt it could have been at a different time. How does no one see Haley was bordering on a breakdown the entire time? Great job by Joy at the end. Very emotional.

Nathan and Jamie scenes were uber lame. I may have nightmares tonight.

KC and LP Fan

THIS ^ times 100. Seriously, I'm just so disappointed where this show has gone. It doesn't even feel like One Tree Hill to me anymore. OTH will always be my favorite show of all time, but I definitely will try and push this season out of memory.

serendipity or fate

I, unfortunately, watched the show tonight. It was like a train wreck... a really awful train wreck that I couldn't look away from.

And this:

sums up my thoughts perfectly. Amazing post.

allybubba

Omg, IKR?

What a horrible, HORRIBLE way to start of the ~long awaited episode.

But really now. Let's not recycle awesome stuff for not so awesome stuff.

qwerty101

Ohh okay thank you for refreshing my memory, yes exactly it was random and probably brought up for the reason you stated.

diamond gothic

Thank god the other NJ scenes were 10x better then the sneak peek. LOL. I loved whenever Nate would talk about Haley and when he brought up Lucas as well. Way too many hints on having another kid, no fair if it all doesn't go anywhere.

Now onto Haley. AWESOME. Gah so much for her.

I won't lie while I prefer the way they are writing HQ now, and while I do think they have chemistry...IDK, Shantel's acting is back to being just mediocre. She stepped up in the Lydia arc, but I agree that Tay and HT scenes right about now would have been sooo much better. Still, the writing is improving and I like that there's more balance in their scenes now, but yeah something is missing that stops their scenes from having that WOW factor and that magic that Joy/Lindsey share. But I still enjoy their scenes. I just wish I didn’t have Taylor to compare, LOL.

The final Haley scene, sooo sad . So heart breaking. Who in the world didn't want to just reach into their tv and give her a hug?

The BH was good. I liked that Haley got teary eyed when she told Brooke not to give up.

NH scene More chemistry in 2 seconds, then most couples have had on this show in whole seasons.

Joy's acting = phenomenal.

Haley's got a major storyline. I guess miracles do happen.

All the other storylines and characters I couldn’t care less about? Someone hand me a bucket.

SarMil23

The title of the episode was really good...
I didn’t like how Brooke was calling Julian Boyfriend, as a Brooke/Lucas fan, that’s just not right.
Mouth/Lauren/Skills, I’m SO over triangles. HATE what Moth/Lauren are doing to Skills.
Why does Nathan never go to any events?
Wish I seen Haley’s reaction to the Pregnancy test.
Grubbs’ voice is amazing.
Katie, go away. NOONE likes you.
I liked Quinn’s photos...
Nathan/Jamie shaving scene, love.
Alex looked Gorgeous... Wow.
What Julian said to Alex was HARSH.
CHASE! <3
Rock Band actually made me smile. These two goofing off was cute.
Always try to save me. I love Alex, but yeah.
I love Brooke Davis.
Nathan reading to Jamie? This was my favourite scene. It didn't seem pushed at all, it was just so natural.
Nathan sporting a litte scruff. <3
Haley/Brooke. Need more of these, longer scenes would be great.
SO, so glad Quinn was there for Haley.
Nathan looked upset when Haley said the test was negative.
I don’t think I’ve ever seen Haley so broken in the Nathan/Haley hug.
Clay/Quinn kiss, Brooke/Julian kiss but no Nathan/Haley? Sad.
Clay is sad to, he looked really pale all night...
Haley, you broke my heart.
Was there another time jump?