Spoilers - Gilmore Girls ~ Luke/Lorelai ~ Analysis & Speculation #269 - Page 20

lancer1993 · 09-01-2006, 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dream**** (View Post)

I dunno. that's what cheaters always say..."It was never about the sex"
Its always about the sex, otherwise it just wouldn't matter.
YOU WOULDN't HAVE HAD IT THEN!
She could have stopped at a hug.
I believe in the back of her mind she knew what could happen and wanted to hurt Luke because she felt he had hurt her and didn't want her.
She felt his non-answer to the ultiimatum was her ticket to ride.
(agh the pun!)

and hello....Why bother being engaged if you don't want a commitment?
That is no kind of logic.

BUt, when it comes down to it.
There is no logic in TVland.
People commit and quit at the drop of a backwards baseball hat.....and have short memories and short or unseen conversations.
I am anxious too to see how these 2 work it out.
I have still have hope since we know she breaks up with Christopher.

I usually bring my Ipod in my car. but my hubby's doesn't have a hook up...and since his gas is free (company car) I try to drive his.
But fortunately we have rock and alternative stations...the alternative one has a short playlist though.

Yep the only thing to look forward to is HOW do they get back together and the FACT Dopey is gone mid season.

Anyone else see the irony that Lorelai wanted the "Whole Package" but will be alone again and Luke will have most of what she wanted!

ETA

Quote:

Originally Posted by WhiteChocMocha

Responding to some earlier posts:
Lorelai's actions can be twisted and explained and excused however one pleases. However, that final scene was an act of betrayal. No way around that and I agree with Bootie, the moment Luke hears the words "I slept with Chris" he won't be able to think of anything else but how the woman who said she loved him just the night before, managed to end up in bed (intentionally or not) with the man he despises the most. The car crashing into the diner seems to be a huge symbolism of how the world around him was falling apart and he didn't even know the magnitude (until Lorelai utters those words, that is).
Nice posts everyone.

Good Post

So nothing new over night?

dreamslut · 09-01-2006, 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ciaobella (View Post)

Love that argument. If it was never about the sex, then why didn't they play checkers instead. Geesh. Lorelai better own up to this, but I bet she blames it on Luke....that he drove her to it.

Haha.
This reminds me of Who Framed Roger Rabbit when Jessica Rabbit plays pattycake with some one else.
"Not Pattycake!"

Mots15 · 09-01-2006, 02:36 PM

Keep posting. I'll grab the new thread. I believe Bootie had to leave.

elle26 · 09-01-2006, 02:37 PM

Aww, how sad is it that NAIL is on and I don't want to watch it? I mean I have no interest in seeing Luke accept Lorelai's proposal, or their hot first kiss as an engaged couple in the gazebo, or even them in bed together. So sad. Sniff.

Mots15 · 09-01-2006, 02:46 PM

So according to the EW article (which is linked on the MT and I can't access at the moment), Emily is hosting the cotillion for Stars Hollow kids? That's... weird. And awesome. All at once.

I smell Luke/Emily scenes.. or at least scene.

Katiegg108 · 09-01-2006, 02:58 PM

The EW article says that Lorelai slept with Chris "immediately after fighting wiht her fiance" so, I dont know if that's just their recap, but it seems like LL didn't break up to them....

lancer1993 · 09-01-2006, 03:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Katiegg108 (View Post)

The EW article says that Lorelai slept with Chris "immediately after fighting wiht her fiance" so, I dont know if that's just their recap, but it seems like LL didn't break up to them....

What we have been saying for months!

Louise 333 · 09-01-2006, 03:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Katiegg108 (View Post)

The EW article says that Lorelai slept with Chris "immediately after fighting wiht her fiance" so, I dont know if that's just their recap, but it seems like LL didn't break up to them....

of course they hadn't broken up.

Everybody has his own view about cheating , being in a relationship means, techically or not butshe said to his fiancée I love you,so doesn't matter what she has said before she went away(and she didn't said ok we're done..and it would have feel not tecnhnically cheating in that case, but it would been very sad for both of them)..she told him :

I love you..so I'm quite sure Luke wont' think that the woman that has just told him she loves him could be able to sleep with someone else.

They're not two young teenagers ..we're talking about tweo peolple that were coming from 8 years of friendship that the moment they chose to date it wasn't simply a date, they already knew each other, that meant much more..and doesn't matter her intention what has happened between two persons deeply connected was a fight, huge one , but not a break up at all, there would had been something bigger to put an end to their relationship....like sleeping with Christopher.

Ok now I really need to focus on the moment she will say good bye to Dopey.

vaso · 09-01-2006, 03:18 PM

I really don't like where this season is going.
I hope the experiment lasts until hiatus or before but i don't see light at the end of the tunnel. Nothing that has been said so far makes me optimistic.