Fan Forum - The Ponds {AmyღRory} #4: He was willing to jump off a building rather than lose her.

Fan Forum (https://www.fanforum.com/)

- Doctor Who (https://www.fanforum.com/f126/)

- - The Ponds {AmyღRory} #4: He was willing to jump off a building rather than lose her. (https://www.fanforum.com/f126/ponds-%7Bamy%E1%83%A6rory%7D-4-he-willing-jump-off-building-rather-than-lose-her-63167578/)

I cried and I usually reserve that for Doctors.

Yep CommanderM-crying for outgoing Doctors since Doctor Number 4. *mopes*

I cried watching "Vincent and the Doctor", gosh that ep was so sad and Tony Curran is just brilliant. :cry:

Ten's very last ep was hard to watch, I know even after seeing Eleven's face I was still crying. :lol:

Vincent and the Doctor is an amazing episode. I'm naturally an empathetic person so thinking about how it would feel to learn that you become a hugely popular artist when you think you're not likely to be remembered by anyone is just :thud:

Oddly enough, I don't remember having a hugely emotional response to Eleven becoming Twelve. :look: I don't really know why...

As for when Amy and Rory left, I was actually left confused for reasons I won't get into now, so that sort of put a damper on my feelings of sadness...this'll make more sense when you've watched the episode. :P :lol:

I finally watched "The Angels Take Manhattan" and boy oh boy, that was sad and heartbreaking to watch. :cry:

But overall I felt underwhelmed by it and thought the Ponds deserved a better exit. :shrug: I felt that it was too much for a companion exit and would have preferred "Power of Three" to be their last seeing as they were already thinking of leaving the Doctor in that ep. I also read somewhere that Karen Gillan wanted a final exit for her character, one that would not require her to be back on the show. So I guess Moffat incorporated the Weeping Angels into the SL to make that happen. The paradox just made all the timey wimey thing really confusing but even though the Ponds technically lived, they wouldn't be able to see the Doctor and even Brian which is very sad. However, what happened to them is still in tune with how heartbreaking all the companion exits have been (at least on New Who).

Maybe because Eleven isn't your favorite Doctor? Although Ten is my favorite, I do have a feeling that I'll cry at Eleven's regeneration ep when I watch it soon. :look: :lol:

I also finally watched those BTS vids of the ep and cried even more. Karen and Arthur crying on their last day and Karen crying during the graveyard scene. Matt Smith crying when he was reading the Afterword. UGH. :cry:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Musickat18 (Post 85671103)

Oddly enough, I don't remember having a hugely emotional response to Eleven becoming Twelve. :look: I don't really know why...

As for when Amy and Rory left, I was actually left confused for reasons I won't get into now, so that sort of put a damper on my feelings of sadness...this'll make more sense when you've watched the episode. :P :lol:

well for me i was the same i personal didn't like matts exciit it didn't make sense to me it was drag out than to quick i always thought he deserved way better .. some say it was better than david year long good bye but i enjoy davids it was a proper goodbye. . I haven't since matts left re watched that whole last episode i just didnt enjoy it enough .. i will do a re watch soon but ive never felt the need to

Quote:

Originally Posted by L i N d $ @ y (Post 85679555)

Oh the ponds excit another one that could ofbeen done better and the reason was the angels 1st time appearing on the show it wss wow they are so scary than they kept coming back and i wasnt as scared anymore so they where just annoying. . Again the ending of how they left was quick just like matts just boom gone no lead up when younthink wow your are truly good .. i do like the after word letter but donnas , rose where alot more ssdder than that

Karen did want a final goodbye i think she wanted to end it and no having to always come back .. but it is doctor who anythig can happen

And yet Karen was willing to come back and help see Matt Smith off in his final story.

That's very true.

I loved Vincent and the Doctor and it also made me cry.

I also cried when Rory and Amy left.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CommanderM (Post 85681137)

And yet Karen was willing to come back and help see Matt Smith off in his final story.

Thats true she loves matt

Quote:

Originally Posted by Summer Falls (Post 85680398)

I agree. I wasn't scared seeing the Angels anymore, it was bordering on annoying. And laughable when the Statue of Liberty was a Weeping Angel too? :lol:

Quote:

Karen did want a final goodbye i think she wanted to end it and no having to always come back .. but it is doctor who anythig can happen

We can only get the Ponds through flashbacks or a mention now. I really hate that Brian wasn't even able to see them again after they left. :(

Quote:

Originally Posted by L i N d $ @ y (Post 85700426)

I agree. I wasn't scared seeing the Angels anymore, it was bordering on annoying. And laughable when the Statue of Liberty was a Weeping Angel too? :lol:

We can only get the Ponds through flashbacks or a mention now. I really hate that Brian wasn't even able to see them again after they left. :(

yer weeping angels not scary .. there should be a moment when we see what happens to their parents moffat didnt include that and he should of

Ponds are amazing for life i love them i still feel like amy will just stop by legends

Quote:

Originally Posted by Summer Falls (Post 85713398)

Ponds are amazing for life i love them i still feel like amy will just stop by legends

GAAAAAAH. I would love for Karen to guest star on LoT after she's done on GotG. :lol: Rip's wife is dead, maybe he doesn't save her and he ends up with this new character played by Karen (in my dreams). :lmao: