S10 Top 8 Performance and Results Shows!
 

SCOTTY MCCREERY :bawl: he was so flawless!

everyone was really good tonight though! i normally do not like paul, but i thought he was good. the one that i thought faltered though was Haley. it's really her time to go :nod:

James-i've always been a mega James fan! :love: and he was amazing tonight...i love that he stood up for what he believed in and do outstanding! thud:

Stefano-surprising song pick but he was amazing!! :love:

I can't believe the egos on some of these contestants. It's totally turning me off. :P Like, you didn't win yet.

I am amazed how pointless the judges panel is this season. They might as well eliminate them and let the contestants perform 3-minute sets, and then just have the voting public choose. Cause hearing them praise people who don't deserve it, week in and out, is becoming counterproductive.

Scotty, Lauren & Stefano were my faves tonight. I :love: those three!

Not a bad night at all! I loved almost everyone, except for a couple that I just don't care about.

James and Lauren were my top favorites this week. Scotty and Casey did really well too. I thought all their choices fit really well with their styles and their versions were great.

What James did is something you save for finale night, after the votes have been tabulated, not something you do during the process of people choosing the next American Idol. I was insulted by that, honestly. It was so self-indulgent. Can they just have 1 'Simon Week' and just bring him back to asses the current crop? Please!

OMG the judges are so useless it's not even funny. I mean, you know it's bad when Randy is the bad guy. And even he's incapable of actual criticism.

Loved Stefano as per usual, LOVED Hayley, I don't know what the judges wanted. HATED Jacob and as always I don't think Scotty's good enough to stay at this point. But for some reason, on dialidol, him and Jacob are ALWAYS the only ones predicted to be safe. GRRR!

God, I hope Stefano doesn't go out tonight... top 8 is notoriously a bad week for me :(

OMG Lauren & Scotty duet AGAIN :thud: I :love: them so much!!

...I hate this show.

so happy with the results! :love: go James and Stefano!!

I only liked Scotty this week! :look: Even Lauren, that I love, I wasn't enjoying... :(

Sad Paul left, I prefer to watch him than Stefano, Jacob, Casey, Haley and James...
THANK GOD FOR ANOTHER SCOTTY & LAUREN DUET! :thud: Seriosly, I loved it! :thud:

I was commenting with my friend that yesterday... they don't critique ANYONE! It's so annoying! Everything and everyone is beautiful, amazing, etc :blah: I miss critiques! The judges are making me angry... :mad: Even Paula Abdul had something to say once in a while, come on!

Was James at least in the bottom 3? :look:

I am so indifferent to Paul. I just feel like, he wasn't getting any better and he wasn't showing us anything new. He really needed a Casey James, "Jealous Guy" moment, and he didn't bring one.

Should we even refer to them as judges? How about "Special Guest Stars"?

^Nope it was Haley, Stefano and Paul in the bottom 3.

Lauren and Scotty's duet was amazing! Love that they keep pairing them up :love:

Haley :cry: Sad for her, it should've been James. (WHO I HONESTLY DO NOT UNDERSTAND WHY HE'S THERE IN THE 1st PLACE) ---- but, this isn't the James-bashing thread, so I'll digress.