*Stacy*

Just a temp mod for now.

Cool. Just started a thread for David H. I loved him in Hollywood so let's see what happens.

Are we allowed to talk about song choices here?

howmuchforhappy

Yes we are. Since this is the spoiler thread, I think it's safe to say that anyone in here is looking for the same things. Do you have any info on that?

rummagingforanswers

If you have any info on song choices, do spill!

PaceNJoForever

Here's pictures of the girls performance:

http://foxflash.com/div.php/main/pag...246z1z6&page=1

And apparently Kady gets criticized on song choice and the way she looks. Not sure how true it is because the person who told me has never told me anything before but I guess we'll see tonight.

rummagingforanswers

Aw, I hope that doesn't happen!

About Kady Malloy being critisized, I mean.

*Stacy*

Thanks for the girls pictures. I did have an idea on songs yesterday, but didn't know we could post them. If I find anything, I'll post.

PaceNJoForever

I saw a list of songs but those were confirmed fake. Only a few more hours to find out anyways.

rumagingforanswers- Yeah, I'm hoping that doesn't happen either.

howmuchforhappy

Well that sucks if Simon criticized Kady's outfit. I know it's a dress, but it doesn't look bad from the pic. Hmm.

*Stacy*

That's a bummer about Kady. They can be so harsh.

rummagingforanswers

But Kady is so classically sexy. So you'd think they'd point that out, like they did with Antonella...not insult her.

PaceNJoForever

from JoesPlace's blog:

Order of performance:

1. Carly Smithson – “Crazy On You” by Heart
2. Syesha Mercado – “Me And Mr. Jones (changed from Mrs. to Mr.) by Billy Paul
3. Brooke White – “You’re So Vain” by Carly Simon
4. Ramiele Malubay – “Don’t Leave Me This Way” by Thelma Houston
5. Kristy Lee Cook – “You’re No Good” by Linda Ronstadt
6. Amanda Overmyer – “Carry On My Wayward Son” by Kansas
7. Alaina Whitaker – “Hopelessly Devoted To You” by Olivia Newton-John
8. Alexandrea Lushington – “If You Leave Me Now” by Chicago
9. Kady Malloy – “Magic Man” by Heart
10. Asia’h Epperson – All By Myself by Celine Dion

from ebayrawks @idf:
Carly: "He (Simon) said that Carly is the one for the girls to beat."
Syesha: "They did not like her song choice at all."
Brooke: "I don't remember what was said but I'm sure that she is safe."
Ramielle: "They did not like Ramielle."
Kristy: --
Amanda: "He (Simon) did not like Amanda's performance and was rude about her clothing and look."
Alaina: "He (Simon) said Alaina look liked her grandmother picked out her clothes. Alaina did quite well with the song. Simon said he liked her but hated her clothing. Also, I think Randy did not like the song choice."
Alexandra: "I think she could be in danger. Sorry."
Kady: "Simon said that Kady is better on film (like the little clips they show before they sing) but she doesn't come across well when she sings. No they did not like her performance."
Asia'h: "Randy and Paula liked her but Simon said that her voice isn't good enough to sing that song. Simon said that Asia'h did have a good enough voice to sing All By Myself."

"Everyone...I cannot remember every comment that the judges said about every contestant. In general, they did not like tonight's performances. One judges may have liked it and the others didn't. I say that Ramielle did not get a good review and someone comes back and says that she did. Maybe we will all see tomorrow night. Obviously, I heard incorrectly or they did."

All spoilers are here. I just picked them all out from posts and summarized it above.

PaceNJoForever

I'm most excited for Brooke's performance tomorrow. I like that song and from what it seems she does a good job on it.

I hadn't heard "Magic Man" before so I listened to a clip and before I read how Kady did I knew it would be a not so good one. So we'll see how that goes tomorrow.

I like Alexandrea's song choice but I'm curious as to how that will sound. I wasn't a fan of her last week.

I'm confused about the Asia'h spoiler because the two sentences say two opposite things.

-res cogitans-

I hate simon right now. ugh.

howmuchforhappy

Thanks for those! Too bad I found them a little late. But I'm totally sizing it up now.

london grammar

Apparently, this girl has been right about her S6 and S7 leaks.


The Top 36:
americanidol: Our Top 36 of American Idol 8 Is...