American Idol #10: The judges are back with a new season & amazing talent!
 

I think JLo was one of my favorite judges:look:

Thanks for the new one!

I liked JLo and I couldn't stand the season with Mariah and Nicki, their drama was too much. :shrug: :crazy:

^That season was irrelevant, which is why I didn’t include them in the pics in the OP. :lol:

I love the 3 seasons with Keith, J-Lo, & Harry! Harry will always be my favorite judge! :D :love: I was so mad when they cancelled his daytime show after 2 seasons. :mad: Because we need a 16th season of Ellen... :rolleyes:

Anyway... :lol:

ETA:

Kelly Clarkson reveals extreme weight loss at Simon Cowell's Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony

That season with Mariah and Nikki was awful, I felt sorry for Keith :lol:

Yeah, poor Keith! :lol: I’m surprised he came back the next season, but maybe he was told Nikki & Mariah wouldn’t be coming back, so he agreed. :lol:

Speaking of Keith! :P
Carrie Underwood (And Her Baby Bump) Make an Appearance at Keith Urban Show: Watch

Thanks, she's amazing :nod:

I rather like Ellen though! :nod:

But I don't see why they cancelled his show either. :shrug:

Ellen was an OK judge but sort of bland when she was on.

I liked Ellen but she didn't want to hurt people's feelings with her critiques :nod:

Yeah, she really wasn’t cut-out to be a judge on the show. :lol:

Yeah she was too nice to be the right kind of critical when it needed to be said. :nod:

Just a note about the OP, it's listing last season as 16 and the next as 17 when really it's a reboot on a new network, so should it not be Season 1 and 2 under ABC?

Thanks for pointing that out, but it’s not a reboot. It’s the same show, it just got put on a different network after a few years. IMDb even lists it as having 16 seasons. Like Last Man Standing or Brooklyn Nine-Nine changed networks for their upcoming seasons, but they’re not starting over at “Season 1”. I know it’s kinda confusing, but, to me, it’d be even more confusing to have it as Season 1a, Season 1b, etc. so I’m just keeping the seasons in numerical order. :)

Never knew that, only because it's the 1st season, 2nd season on the new network, they list it as such elsewhere is all. :nod:

Plus with all the judge replacements, its like a reboot 5 times over! :lol:

I'm just glad they brought it back :nod:

I agree Janice, plus I like this panel of judges.

What is your guys' personal favourites to be a judging panel if you could pick? (That includes anyone, not just who's been on the show)