Queer As Folk - Season 5 Discussion #45 ~ When love grows up - Page 6

Sia · 07-30-2017, 07:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fmaldy24 (View Post)

I like your thinking though

It could work you never know. I think more and more people are pushing for it - especially with all the other shows that are getting reboots at the moment.

Thats truth. BUT really id it would be fans who would contribute, they should have some say in whats going to happen. Imagine contribuing money and then your dreams will be crashed. That would be betrayal.

fmaldy24 · 07-30-2017, 07:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sia (View Post)

Thats truth. BUT really id it would be fans who would contribute, they should have some say in whats going to happen. Imagine contribuing money and then your dreams will be crashed. That would be betrayal.

True and that's probably why they wouldn't do it because they would want to write the story the way they wanted - we know the actors have said that often

**SojournHeart11** · 07-30-2017, 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sia (View Post)

Exactly, i could not accept if they would separate them at the end of potential reboot. It would be better if they would not be together in the beginning of reboot but would reunite by the end. That would destroy our fantasy world. And compromise between loft and coutryside is ideal, even in that fanfic i told you about yesterday, they keep both.
But you know, i am unsure about cowlip. Because they clearly said they dont evolve their characters according to wishes of fans. And although they did not meant 513 as breakup, we never know what they would come up with later. But if they would separate them forever, they would certainly piss most of the fans,

I could get with this. They would have to literally finish in the reboot where they left off in the original show's run.

Sia · 07-30-2017, 09:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SojournHeart11 (View Post)

I could get with this. They would have to literally finish in the reboot where they left off in the original show's run.

Yes, and even if it would seem hopeless for them to see each other again in the beginning, the end would have to be their happyend. But it will stay in our dreams probably

**SojournHeart11** · 07-30-2017, 01:42 PM

The possibilities are still endless.

Sia · 07-30-2017, 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SojournHeart11 (View Post)

The possibilities are still endless.

Yes and i doubt writers would go expected way.

fmaldy24 · 07-30-2017, 06:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SojournHeart11 (View Post)

The possibilities are still endless.

The possibilities are endless and I think that's why there is so many fanfics - everyone will have a different idea and thought about how things could've gone - did they end up together or not, how long did it take them to see each other again, did they live in the country or the loft or both, did Justin stay in NYC or did Brian move there or did Justin move back?

The only thing I've seen the writers say was they didn't see this as an end but that they would see each other again but how they saw that happening I don't know. In twelve years their vision may have changed as well - society has changed a lot in those twelve years as well so they may see a very different ending to what they once envisioned as well.

I think the thing though was that just felt so final with their last love scene that it didn't feel in some ways that they would be seeing each other again in the way we wanted them to.

Sia · 07-31-2017, 06:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fmaldy24 (View Post)

The possibilities are endless and I think that's why there is so many fanfics - everyone will have a different idea and thought about how things could've gone - did they end up together or not, how long did it take them to see each other again, did they live in the country or the loft or both, did Justin stay in NYC or did Brian move there or did Justin move back?

The only thing I've seen the writers say was they didn't see this as an end but that they would see each other again but how they saw that happening I don't know. In twelve years their vision may have changed as well - society has changed a lot in those twelve years as well so they may see a very different ending to what they once envisioned as well.

I think the thing though was that just felt so final with their last love scene that it didn't feel in some ways that they would be seeing each other again in the way we wanted them to.

Yes, it felt quiet final. And I was not so much worried about Justin because he was emotionally stable, but for Brian it was much worse.

**SojournHeart11** · 07-31-2017, 12:13 PM

Very true, Fiona. Not to mention, we got quite a few fics depicting how tough a knocked-up Brian is when he can't go club-hopping for obvious reasons. The amount of creativity fanfics exude is astonishing.

Sia · 07-31-2017, 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SojournHeart11 (View Post)

Very true, Fiona. Not to mention, we got quite a few fics depicting how tough a knocked-up Brian is when he can't go club-hopping for obvious reasons. The amount of creativity fanfics exude is astonishing.

What you mean he cant go clubhopping? After he is married to Justin?