Emilie de Ravin - Claire Appreciation #16: Who's on top? - Page 5

Squireepiphone · 05-01-2007, 03:40 AM

what I want to know is how did they find the plane if half of it is on the Island.....and I don't think it's purgatory cause they have contact with the outside world and can affect the outside world.

**Jazz** · 05-01-2007, 05:53 AM

Well, I think the island is kind of like on the Bermuda triangle, she found something but that's not to say she found the island.

Also, I thought the entire plane was in the island. It split in half but I believe they found the other end when they were on one of their missions?

**LilMouse** · 05-01-2007, 08:54 AM

Ben knew about the Red Sox winning the World Series...remember he showed Jack everything that happened in the outside world and what he could go back to. I guess that can still happen in purgatory, but I don't like the purgatory idea and tptb already told us a bunch of times that it's not purgatory so for them to go back on their word would be

Quote:

she found something but that's not to say she found the island.

we won't know unless she shows up with a boat

Didn't the plane fall in the ocean? I can't remember.

Monique19 · 05-01-2007, 10:50 AM

basically the plane is all over the island, it went in pieces, part in water and the rest in land.

We'll see what happens, I honestly don't have any speculation as yet cause this new info just came.

xXxLost-in-SawyerxXx · 05-01-2007, 01:02 PM

I just think it's too confusing

so I think I'll just sit back and watch this story unfold

although I gotta admit if it is purgatory I think it's a lazy way to end it- especially with the amount of time the writers have claimed it isn't purgatory

**Jazz** · 05-02-2007, 05:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LilMouse (View Post)

Ben knew about the Red Sox winning the World Series...remember he showed Jack everything that happened in the outside world and what he could go back to. I guess that can still happen in purgatory, but I don't like the purgatory idea and tptb already told us a bunch of times that it's not purgatory so for them to go back on their word would be

Hmm...doesn't matter...if they are in purgatory, doesn't mean they don't know what's going on in the real world. I mean...they are halfway between worlds and what if Ben is some kind of messenger from the other side? Who knows...there is alot of things.

In any case, this show is full of questions and never has any answers.

**meretwins** · 05-02-2007, 08:33 AM

i don't think the purgatory theory works because not all of them would have had a reason to wind up there....maybe the island is like the bermuda triangle where strange stuff happens....

**LilMouse** · 05-02-2007, 11:19 AM

I agree, mere. Sure, Claire was sorta mean to her mom, but I don't think she did anything that would deserve being stuck in purgatory. And Sun may be a tough cookie when threatened, but she's not a bad person. Same with Jack. He is controlling, but I wouldn't send him to purgatory to work off his sins.

Quote:

what if Ben is some kind of messenger from the other side?

like an angel? man, that would be spooky if Ben was an angel.

**Jazz** · 05-03-2007, 07:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LilMouse (View Post)

like an angel? man, that would be spooky if Ben was an angel.

An angel? No way.

But a messenger of some kind anyways.

In any case, they said the plane was found on the bottom of the ocean, guess that explains alot of things about where they found the plane.

I kind of zoned out in the episode. Jack and Juliet are hiding something... and it almost sounded like good news about something. Again, Locke made someone else do his own dirty work. First Boone, now Sawyer. Poor guy.

I am not liking Locke more and more. He's abit...off. If anything, he'll get anyone who knows him killed.

I'm intrigued about the next episode and how they will handle Juliet's betrayal.

**LilMouse** · 05-03-2007, 09:26 AM

I'm just really hoping Juliet isn't on the others side. I like her character and I want to believe she & Jack are coming up with a plan that will benefit the other Losties.

Monique19 · 05-03-2007, 12:32 PM

Why does Kate always have to go and tell Jack everything, I said it to my mom, I bet you she going to tell Jack what Sayid and the others said. She talks too much.

Can't stand Jack, can barely stand Juliet so you know seeing them was annoying, I don't blame the beach people not to trust Jack, he always keeps things from them and think what he says goes. He trusts Juliet so they are to automatically trust her, plz give me a break. In time I might like Juliet but not at the moment.

Still don't know what to make of Locke but I am intrigued

Sawyer finally got to avenge his parents death.

**LilMouse** · 05-03-2007, 01:32 PM

Hopefully whatever Locke is up to will help the Losties,

My mom was yelling at Kate too. I think everyone was mad at her last night

Quote:

Jack, he always keeps things from them and think what he says goes

that annoys me too. I rather follow Sayid.

**Jazz** · 05-04-2007, 06:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monique19 (View Post)

Why does Kate always have to go and tell Jack everything, I said it to my mom, I bet you she going to tell Jack what Sayid and the others said. She talks too much.

Because Kate is in love with Jack. And no matter what happens, she's always going to go back to him and tell him things. While others may not trust him, she does. She always will. Love makes you do things.

The preview has Jack saying, "We have some catching up to do" so I suspect that he's going to reveal some kind of plan. I wonder if his getting close to Juliet is a way to fish for information to add to the plan that he may have?

xXxLost-in-SawyerxXx · 05-04-2007, 07:51 AM

Quote:

The preview has Jack saying, "We have some catching up to do" so I suspect that he's going to reveal some kind of plan. I wonder if his getting close to Juliet is a way to fish for information to add to the plan that he may have?

Nah, Jack isn't that clever

- who knows??

**LilMouse** · 05-04-2007, 12:47 PM

Enough with all the triangles.
Kate should just stop leading Sawyer on if she really wants Jack. I love Skate, but I don't want Sawyer to be fooled anymore.