James Van Der Beek - All time fave DJ song survivor #3 - Here we go again - it's torture^infinity!

Chase.This.Light · 07-22-2009, 05:02 PM

So here we have it, the ultimate DJ song survivor - take two.

Take 2 because we did this already.

Season 1

"Broken Road" - Melodie Crittenden
"Say Goodnight" - Beth Nielsen Chapman
"I'll Be" - Edwin McCain
"Full Of Grace" - Sarah McLachlan
"I'll Stand By You" - The Pretenders

Season 2

"London Rain" - Heather Nova
"Kiss The Rain" - Billie Myers
"Feels Like Home" - Chantal Kreviazuk
"Frozen Charlotte" - Natalie Merchant
"Wait For The Way" - Beth Nielsen Chapman

Season 3

"Let That Be Enough" - Switchfoot
"I Do" - Jude
"Daydream Believer" - Katie Holmes / James Van Der Beek
"Little Things" - Chantal Kreviazuk
"Never Ending" - Wood

Season 4

"How You've Grown" - Natalie Merchant
"Fields Of Gold" - Eva Cassidy
"Souvenirs" - Mary Beth Maziarz
"Daydream Believer" - Mary Beth Maziarz
"Aftershocks" - Mary Beth Maziarz

Season 5

"This Way" - Jewel
"Thistle" - Breech
"Question" - Old 97's
"Taking Chances" - Abra Moore
"Loud" - Matt Nathanson

Season 6

"Your Love" - Laura Doyle
"Confessions" - Lea Longo
"As I Lay Me Down" - Sophie B Hawkins
"The Drifter" - David Poe
"It's Not" - Aimee Mann

How it works

This time all of the top 5 songs from the 6 seasons will be up for elimination. We'll eliminate songs until only 3 or 5 songs remaining and then we assign points the way we usually do.

Vote away

"Wait For The Way" - Beth Nielsen Chapman

"Never Ending" - Wood

"Aftershocks" - Mary Beth Maziarz

"Loud" - Matt Nathanson

"It's Not" - Aimee Mann

"Full Of Grace" - Sarah McLachlan

"Frozen Charlotte" - Natalie Merchant

"Little Things" - Chantal Kreviazuk

"Daydream Believer" - Mary Beth Maziarz

"Taking Chances" - Abra Moore

"The Drifter" - David Poe

"I'll Stand By You" - The Pretenders

"I'll Be" - Edwin McCain

"Feels Like Home" - Chantal Kreviazuk

"Daydream Believer" - Katie Holmes / James Van Der Beek

"Souvenirs" - Mary Beth Maziarz

"Question" - Old 97's

"As I Lay Me Down" - Sophie B Hawkins

"Say Goodnight" - Beth Nielsen Chapman

"Kiss The Rain" - Billie Myers

"I Do" - Jude

"Fields Of Gold" - Eva Cassidy

"Thistle" - Breech

"Confessions" - Lea Longo

"Broken Road" - Melodie Crittenden

"London Rain" - Heather Nova

"Let That Be Enough" - Switchfoot

"How You've Grown" - Natalie Merchant

"This Way" - Jewel

"Your Love" - Laura Doyle

Chase.This.Light · 07-22-2009, 05:04 PM

I've decided to start a new thread for this as there will no doubt be a bit of discussion regarding the results.

*Puts everyone out of their misery*

Winner of the Ultimate Dawson and Joey
song survivor...take 1

Broken Road - Melodie Crittenden

Can I just say, I had a laugh comiling this list. We were so funny, practically killing one another when a favourite was voted for. V - you must be bald by now and hopefully aren't in need of any medical help. Kimberly, you have more lives than a cat. And I'm just glad I managed to not kill anyone for voting of my faves like "How You've Grown"

Final rankings

"Broken Road" - Melodie Crittenden
"Kiss The Rain" - Billie Myers
"London Rain" - Heather Nova
"This Way" - Jewel
"Your Love" - Laura Doyle
"Let That Be Enough" - Switchfoot
"How You've Grown" - Natalie Merchant
"I'll Be" - Edwin McCain
"Fields Of Gold" - Eva Cassidy
"Say Goodnight" - Beth Nielsen Chapman
"Thistle" - Breech
"Confessions" - Lea Longo
"I Do" - Jude
"Feels Like Home" - Chantal Kreviazuk
"Daydream Believer" - Mary Beth Maziarz
"Souvenirs" - Mary Beth Maziarz
"As I Lay Me Down" - Sophie B Hawkins
"Daydream Believer" - Katie Holmes / James Van Der Beek
"Question" - Old 97's
"Full Of Grace" - Sarah McLachlan
"I'll Stand By You" - The Pretenders
"Taking Chances" - Abra Moore
"Frozen Charlotte" - Natalie Merchant
"Little Things" - Chantal Kreviazuk
"The Drifter" - David Poe
"Loud" - Matt Nathanson
"Aftershocks" - Mary Beth Maziarz
"Wait For The Way" - Beth Nielsen Chapman
"It's Not" - Aimee Mann
"Never Ending" - Wood

Madison · 07-22-2009, 07:20 PM

Pshew! I'm glad this voting mess is over, that's all I have to say...

Well, that and thanks Karen!

Chase.This.Light · 07-23-2009, 03:35 AM

No opinion on the rankings? I'll start the other version of this survivor on Sunday, maybe.

**Pure.Magic** · 07-23-2009, 12:02 PM

uhm... yay?

Feels like Home, I'll be, Your Love and This way shouldve been higher.

Cant wait for the new one. Cant believe I just said that.

I better grow out some more hair by then.

**JenMixelle** · 07-23-2009, 01:06 PM

I'm just gonna go grey during the next one...

Said all I needed to say when you first posted the list, Karen

Chase.This.Light · 07-23-2009, 01:13 PM

I sort of wonder how different the result will be. Some songs won't be restricted from getting into the top 10 based on where they finished in their respective seasons.

**JenMixelle** · 07-23-2009, 01:17 PM

The results might be different. *hopes*

Chase.This.Light · 07-23-2009, 01:30 PM

It bloody better be better but I am fearful for the worst.

**Pure.Magic** · 07-23-2009, 02:24 PM

It has to be better.

**dcluv** · 07-23-2009, 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

Kimberly, you have more lives than a cat.

i'm excited for us to try it again

**JenMixelle** · 07-23-2009, 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

It has to be better.

Oh if the whip is out, it will be

I still think I'll end up in a corner, crying

Chase.This.Light · 07-23-2009, 04:26 PM

Highlights/debates from the thread 1...

Karen begins to worry about her fave DJ song "How you've Grown".

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcluv (View Post)

Frozen Charlotte ...i was never a big fan of that one

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

I may start worrying about "How You've Grown" now.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

I just listened to both "Frozen Charlotte" and "How You've Grown"...I think I actually prefer "Frozen Charlotte". Because I don't care for her voice, I think I base that on the lyrics of the song.

Frozen Charlotte was voted off and V declared...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

This isnt going your way Karen, is it?

Kimberly votes out "Full Of Grace...

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

People need to quit voting off my faves. Seriously!!!

In a 3 way tie between Taking CHances, Full of Grace and I'll Stand By You - V is unsure how to vote...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

Its has to be between Taking Chances and I'll Stand By You. I love both of them. Argh!!

And Kimberly tries some weird logic on V...

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcluv (View Post)

Full of Grace, V. It will solve your problem of having to choose between Taking Chances and I'll Stand By You

Maddie then starts coaxing V to go her way...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

*whispers* V - Taking Chances...you know you want to.

And V now knows how it feels...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

Woah woah!!!

So this is what it feels like. Usually, Im the one doing it.

Im still undecided, yes, slap me someone!!

She later opts for songs out of a hat.

The first threat or rather, mention of violence is mentioned by...

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

Kimberly, I could hit you right now but I won't. I think it's "nice" that we agree on our love for DJ but when it comes to survivors we don't all tend to be in agreement. I mean nice in a good way, not in an "I just insulted you and everything you stand for" kind of way like some people take it.

I really should know better! Kimberly's response...

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcluv (View Post)

Someone's amused!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

Kimberly and Karen.

This is fun.

Possibly the only time those words have ever been used on this survivor.

In the next round V posts...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

It has to be between Souvenirs and Question.

I shouldnt start fretting and getting confused so early in the round.

And someone (me) can't believe it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

Seriously V, you're trying to kill my top 3 so early on.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JenMixelle (View Post)

OK, I'm gonna get murdered for this, but:

"Souvenirs" - Mary Beth Maziarz

Jen - The Irish Sea has it's use as a defensive mechanism!

Maddie critiques Katie's singing...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

I only voted for it cause I don't think Katie can sing.

Oops.

Karen votes off As I Lay Me Down in order to save Souvenirs and for the second vote off in a row, Jen votes off Souvenirs but another song leaves.

V starts to lose her hair

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

*tears her hair out*

Jen finds a buddy in Deb to vote off Souvenirs

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deb D (View Post)

*wonders if she's unkowingly stumbled into a passionate debate*

To which V advises "Just run from Karen" before being the 4th person to vote out
Souvenirs (after Kimberly)

Disheartened..

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

I can't be bothered counting it up

Souvenirs - too many to save
what's the point - 1

hehe

Karen's votes lead V to ask "How many times do you change your mind?" and learns that "I've always prefered Daydream Believer to Feels Like home".

Karen has a list

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

I think there's a possibility we may all fall out by the end of this.

I've certainly got Kimberly and Jen on a list somewhere

Chase.This.Light · 07-23-2009, 04:27 PM

Due to limited number of smiles...it's in two posts.

We "joke" (yeah right) about how we'll kill one another and will no longer "speak" around the same time Karen and Kimberly have a major breakthrough!! How long will it last?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

I have way too many favorites. DJ had beautiful songs.

This is going to get agonisingly hard later. I can see it. We will weep, and kill each other.

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

Well, it's been nice knowing all of you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

Yeah, I had a good time here too.

Hmm, where's Kimberly's vote?

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

No idea.

Maybe she is fearful for her life.

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

Why do i have a feeling that when kimberly votes she's gonna give us a tie.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcluv (View Post)

Karen -

i'm actually not a huge fan of "Feels Like Home" ....i like the other two better.

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Karen* (View Post)

Kimberly, we voted the same!!! It's like the first time ever!

Feels like Home leaves the survivor and V all but has some sort of meltdown on discovering the news of that and having both Maddie and Jen vote against Confessions.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

Arrrghhhhhhhh!!!!!!!

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!

I LOVE Confessions!!!!!!

And Feels like home lost....

*runs away sobbing*

Remember this date people - 25th April 2009 - the first time V brought the whip to the survivor...this was because no one was voting, not an attempt to coax votes

Maddie is distraught

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

Bye bye "I Do".

Confessions is voted for by loads of people but V refuses to vote for it...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

"I'll Be" - Edwin McCain

Just cuz I dont want to vote off Confessions, and cuz I know it wont make a difference anyway.

Maddie's torture began on May 2nd, V's the day after. May 5th and Maddie refuses to vote anymore.

After Confessions is eliminated V "doesn't know anymore" and on the 6th Maddie goes a little mad..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

AHHHHH!!!! *covers her eyes...and ears* I can't.

But I will...

Say Goodnight as well. But only because it was a little marred for me by the series finale.

In a two-way tie between Thistle and Say Goodnight PM's are sent to Cris and Kimberly to help. They both vote, against each other forcing another tie and Maddie declares "Nora is our only hope"! *dramatic* And Karen goes to find Nora who votes out Thistle.

Madie thanks Nora for voting...kind of.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

Thanks, Nora! But only a little cause you voted off the one I wanted to stay this round...anywho...

Quote:

Originally Posted by *Nora* (View Post)

Well then I'm only a little sorry, Maddie.

Two votes go against Say Goodnight..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pure.Magic (View Post)

Wow, you all wont even let me celebrate the fact the Say goodnight got saved in the last round?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (View Post)

Sorry V! No time...we've got business to handle!

And that's the story of thread 1.

Madison · 07-23-2009, 05:02 PM

That was great Karen! What an awesome run-down of the torture that is voting in one of our survivors. Bravo!