Nashville This or That #3
 

Erin

S3 finale or S4 finale?

S4 finale

Best chapel scene: Scarlett when Beverly was in the hospital or Rayna & Maddie during Deacon's surgery

Scarlett

Mother you'd most like to resurrect: Beverly or Jolene?

Jolene (I always wanted to know what happened right after her husband died when Juliette was 4 years old.)

Which left the deepest wound: Maddie saying in court she was afraid of Deacon or Avery sleeping with Layla

For me, the deepest wound from S4 was Frankie throwing Deacon under the bus at court. That will NEVER be forgiven. But of the two listed below, I'll have to go with Avery sleeping with Layla. Both scenarios were stupid and made no sense. However, Avery sleeping with Layla ruined Avery for me a little bit and I love JJ so that one is a little deeper.

Now that we've grown accustomed to Scarlett's short hair:

Do you want Scarlett to keep her hair short or grow it out long again?

Without a doubt grow it out long again!!! I just think Clare is prettier with long hair. (Not to say she isn't still gorgeous with short hair, I just prefer it longer.)

And speaking of hair lengths. Avery's hair: Shorter like in season 2 or longer as it is now

My absolute favorite Avery hair was 2x21. God help me. But it may have been the whole clean shaven look. I don't mind it long, but I'm not a fan of that sort of in between length. I would not mind seeing a bun. ;) Long-winded answer, going with short.

Since we are talking about hair, it'd be a shame not to mention the auburn goddess. Rayna - straight or curly?

Straight :jaw_drop:

Deyna rings: eternity band or Rayna's wedding ring?

Band.. so so so much (I don't like Rayna's wedding ring :look:)

DR S3 songs (since we didn't get any in S4 :sigh:).. Surrender or The Rivers Between Us

That's a hard one, but I choose Surrender.

Who would make the best Mother-in-law from Hell: Sean's mother or Beverly (before she got all nice in the hospital)

Beverly--she's too unstable.

On Jeff Fordham, Juliette's "He's an ass," as said to Rayna, or Avery's "What an ass," as said to Juliette?

Good one. I commend them both on their instincts, but going with Juliette. If I'm not mistaken Rayna called him an ass too...amazing how he was sainted after death.

Which leads to - who had the better postmortem redemption - Jeff or Beverly?

Beverly, it's hard to top dying because you gave away part of your liver to save your brother.

Who has the worst father: Will or Avery?

(The last few questions have been so good. Made me smile and think about my answers.)

Will's father
(Although both men began to redeem themselves with me in later shows. Avery's dad after Avery and Cadence went back to Ohio and he offered to help in raising his granddaughter Cadence and help Avery find a job. But Will's dad took up for Will against that bully after his wife's funeral and had begun to call Will offering Will some of his mother's things.)

Sexiest scene with person who is not their real love interest: Rayna with Liam or Avery with Serena

This is fun. ETA: Rayna with Liam

Who was cuter with Cadence: Will or Gunnar?