kerbear28

kerbear28

#1 -3 (Amanda, Issi, Stephen)
#11- 2 (Amanda, Keri)

Reign Music
First Half of Season One Epic Songs Survivor
Round 8

Vote for the song you like LEAST.
A song is voted out when it receives 5 votes during one round.
If 48 hours pass with no scene receiving 5 votes, the scene with the most votes is eliminated.

De Medici Queen

Tftnt Keri

NotDoneAbusingYou

Just looking back at the old survivors, I didn't vote in that one, but how the heck did The Coronation win for best episode of season 2? That episode was super boring.

kerbear28

^ Yeah, I remember being surprised by the result of that survivor, too. I don't know what happened. Obviously, I loved Frary working together against Narcisse and the coronation itself, but there were other episodes that I enjoyed more as a whole than 2x03.

De Medici Queen

lol I don't know it wasn't bad but I know I had other favorites too


so... do we want to start a new round?

NotDoneAbusingYou

No. It wasn't bad. Just nowhere near good enough to be the best.

It's been long enough hasn't it? But don't we have to wait for Stephen to start it?

kerbear28

We don't necessarily have to wait for Stephen to start a new round, but I guess it depends on if he wants to wait for more votes before moving on. Obviously, I still want a chance to save Back to You. It meant so much to us as a fandom. Like Amanda (enchantedstarlight) said, we would literally have "sing alongs" and post the lyrics to kill Frary threads. It was (and still is) this anthem of hope that Mary and Francis' love would endure and they would always find their way back to each other. It's honestly so much bigger than the song itself. I think it deserves to be in the top 3.

NotDoneAbusingYou

It wouldn't really be fair to wait. I mean isn't that why we have the 48 hour rule in the first place. Waiting purposely to try and get your favorite to win feels like cheating to me.

De Medici Queen

^ don't feel offended Amanda

let's see if Stephen shows up today if not we will start a new round

ParkDundee

Hi, I was just waiting to see if anyone else wanted to vote (not trying to influence the outcome).

Let's call it. Good-bye #1.

NotDoneAbusingYou

I didn't feel offended, I was just saying we can't go by the rules sometimes and then just bypass them other times because we feel is necessary. That's all. If we don't want to use the 48 hour rule. That's fine, but then we should just get rid of it completely. I wasn't accusing you Stephen, I was just saying waiting makes it feel that way. We didn't wait on any of the other rounds. So we shouldn't wait now. I'm sorry if anyone felt like I was getting defensive.

This one is hard. I'm trying to decide between 2 and 7. They are both so good though. The last few rounds are always the hardest.

kerbear28

^ ^ I appreciate that, Stephen. Thanks for waiting. I honestly wasn't trying to cheat or hold things up. I know we have the 48 hour rule for a reason. I just wanted more people to vote, too. When there are only 4 or 5 votes total in one round, it doesn't really feel like a fair, genuine consensus. Of course, I was hoping more Frary fans would make it over here, too. I'm biased, but I want the Frary vote to be represented. That's why I'm grateful that Stephen posted the reminder in the Frary thread. It's just difficult, because a lot of the regular posters there tend to stick to just the Frary thread and aren't consistently logged on every day. I'm disappointed to lose Back to You, but I understand that music is highly subjective. Amanda is putting together a Frary song survivor, so that should be fun.

Stephen, I should have asked this when we started, but why did you decide not to include "Scotland" and "Charlie Boy" by the Lumineers in this survivor? Those are two of my favs.

I'm glad you didn't feel offended, Amanda. Maybe it would be a good idea to simply extend the rule to 72 hours to make sure everyone has enough time to find the survivor and vote? I agree that if we have a rule, we should stick to it.

UGH, this round is impossible. I'll start by voting for #7 even though I think it's really cool and I love how it increases the tension of the scene. I may change my mind, though...

NotDoneAbusingYou

Keri you must have posted just as I added to my last post. When I updated, it just popped up at me haha I got confused for a second.

I think we should remind more than just the frary threads when we need more votes though, that would skew the voting a little too. We should do it in various active threads to keep it fair.

kerbear28

Yeah, I think we we were posting and editing our posts at the exact same time.

That's true. We should post reminders in other threads to be fair. Which threads do you think we should post in? Sadly, several threads just have you, me and Issi posting in them regularly. Maybe the Mash thread? The Bash/Torrance thread? The Mary/Adelaide thread? The Catherine thread? The Cleith thread? The Catcisse thread? The game threads?

Since we've made it to the top three, I think we should try to get as many people involved as possible. Stephen, do you want to post the reminders? If you want me to help with that, I'd be happy to.