ciaBrysh

Yeah it's probably just a bunch of trolls, there is no way the show got cancelled, the first episode technically didn't air yet

hiddleskittlesღ

Figured. Thank God.

I just saw the pilot.

OMFG. I think I fell in love.

Wow… Now I want to watch the Benedict Cumberbatch version! Not so much to compare, but I do love a good detective show/movie when it’s there for my consumption, so yeah. I want!

Jakls

Cool I'm going to watch it tonight.

RubyGrace

I watched it last night and really liked it, it was a lot of fun. Jonny Lee Miller is great as Holmes, very different to Cumberbatch but still Holmesian in hi interpretation. Lucy Liu was amazing as a believable female Watson, she doesn't take any s**t from him but has her own issues to deal with, and they played off each other very well.

I'm looking forward to seeing how they develop the story from here.

ciaBrysh

I have also been wanting to watch the Cumberbach version, but a few people the the fandom warned me against it due to the ending of the last series and to wait until the next season starts apparently there is some major cliffhanger

RubyGrace

Yeah there is a big cliffhanger. It's a good one, but maybe best to wait if you can.

Here are a couple of cast posters I don't think have been posted yet:

Jakls

I really liked it, looking forward to seeing how it develops.

Thanks for the posters.

hiddleskittlesღ

I wonder who they'll cast as Moriarty?

I just started watching the BBC version and I love it too

GoodWifeObsessed

Yaye just a couple more days until the show premieres - I was too impatient to wait and watched it with that link one of our members provided here - But I'm really excited for all the new episodes to come

Bring it on Sherlock

ciaBrysh

I wonder too!
I also started the BBC Sherlock, I enjoy it I mean...the two shows are not comparable what so ever IMO but both equally as enjoyable

ElizaSparrow

Hi

Me too! And will it be a male or a female? Anything is possible with this show

I'm actually a big, BIG "BBC Sherlock"'s fan, completely fell in love for Benedict, Lou and ALL the cast seriously, and TPTB of that show are so creative, and the show is just so unique compared to all the soap opera kind of shows we're having now

But on the other hand I'm very interested with "Elementary" because:
1. I love Jonny Lee Miller ever since I saw "Emma"
2. Lucy Liu is soooo adorable in the trailer
3. The show definitely seems fun, and it's great to have a female Watson for a change

That said, I don't understand why Americans like to make everything in their own versions, no pun intented, I think it's rather funny

*OldHollywoodStarlet*

I've already seen the pilot and I really enjoyed it. Watched it again tonight and liked it still. It had some great potential. Both Jonny and Lucy were great.

Alexa

i watched and i thought it was okay. it definitely had a similar vibe to the bbc version, but i dont think the characters are nearly as compelling as sherlock and john from Sherlock. But thats JMO.

I dont see any chemistry (friendship even) between lucy and the main guy, but i thought the plot was decent so Im gonna give it a chance.

Jakls

I'll have to rewatch it before next week.

KeepThisaSecret

Caught this last night. It was actually o.k. I think I might continue to watch this.