miranstarr

How about this: Charming realized he couldn't marry her and broke off the betrothal. She gets all "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned" when she sees that he tossed her for the thieving renegade Snow White. She goes to the Evil Queen for revenge, whom promises her a happily ever after in our world. All she has to do is obey EQ/Regina and she can have the life she wanted.

Hmmmm, I wonder if Dr. Whales has been implanting false memories into David. We, the viewers, know that Catherine and David (Charming) can't have been married because Charming crossed over into our world unconscious and dying. He's been in the hospital ever since in a coma. They always say that family members/volunteers should talk to coma patients because although they are in a coma, they can hear everything we say. Perhaps Regina has had Dr. Whale talking about Catherine to David so that when he wakes up, he'll believe what he's being told.

~lipstick

Then it all went wrong because Charming got hurt and ended up in a coma. Yeah, that could work too!

We need to know how the curse works to know how they get the false memories.

miranstarr

Yeah, I don't think he was supposed to get hurt. Maybe a knock on the head. No one even went for Snow White even though she would have been the easiest target, seeing as she'd just given birth and was extremely weak. After all, they only wanted Emma. I guess in the heat of the battle, emotions were running too high.

Anyway, I hope they don't drag this Catherine/David "relationship" out too long. I need that ship to sink soon!

*OldHollywoodStarlet*

Well I think James was a targeted because he had the baby in his arms and of course he wasn't going to let them hurt his little girl or take her. He was going to make sure she got her chance.

Yeah I hope it sinks quick too.

WonderlandGabby

Even though she's not his real wife when she came I was so upset I was thinking "Why do you exists? " The fact that that when he woke up he kinda went off in search for her. And I loved the whole "troll bridge" thing in SB and how the last she read to him was about the troll bridge



You could just see the connection between Mary and David already. I loved it and it broke my heart at the same time! His little smile as she called him Charming there, he didn't hate

miranstarr

Ugh, looking at that last gif makes my heart break all over again for Mary. Damn you, Catherine!! Get off Snow/Mary's man!!

*OldHollywoodStarlet*

I think we were all going "NOOOoooo!" when she walked in. Hopefully it won't last long and just give us some good drama.

I loved that unconsciously he was going to that troll bridge to find Snow. That he was looking for her. Maybe even though she was in danger.

MyLastDayWithoutYou

future theard titles
our love knows no bounds. we wil always find each other
yousaved me. it's the honorable thing to do

the evil queen called Catherine, "Miss Nolan", so they are not married

*OldHollywoodStarlet*

Oh good catch about the Miss. I hope it mean that they are only engaged.

Some nice future titles.

~lipstick

The third gif, his face, his smirk! you could see he was totally blown away by her. Bet he was thinking 'who is this sexy badass with a smart mouth'

I thnk that because he was in a coma and doesn't remember anything he'll be the one most willing to believe in Henry and the first to start remembering things. I bet he's going to have flashes of his fairytale life.

*OldHollywoodStarlet*

Haha I love that smirk too. Yeah I think he was too.

That would be something I would LOVE to see!

~lipstick

And people will be all (and by people I mean Emma and Snow) 'you are just having these false memories because of all the stories henry's been feeding you'

*OldHollywoodStarlet*

Do you think if they go that route that Mary would be more open minded? I mean she looks like she was willing to believe in the latest episode to some degree.

WonderlandGabby

GrhmLz

I can see that as a very real possiblity, yes.