Knight Rook (Wish Hook/Rogers & Alice/Tilly) #1: "This was hers. I kept it to remember her. It's her rook. She has my knight."
 

I opened this thread in the Colin board few weeks ago, thought i hope one here too (i did ask a mod).
This is for people who wants to discuss the story arc with Wish Hook (who is another person not the real Hook hence name of thread) in S7 who is looking for his daughter.
I'm not into S7, but since Wish Hook is here and has a arc, this thread is for that.

Some ppl on tumblr came up with the name for them as Knight Rook. Once the name of his daughter is confirmed it will be added on

Thanks for setting up the thread.

Thanks for the new thread!

Anyone have any theories as to who the daughter is?

Thanks for the Thread, I don't really have a theory myself but I hear a few think it's Alice

I'd be disappointed if it was Alice. I'm sure we'll find out soon, though.

TFTNT

i'm thinking it's Alice too.

I am also on team it's Alice

For me, it would be too obvious for Alice to be his daughter. I'm hoping that
the witch that Drizella and Lady T are holding is his daughter.

I think an Alice reveal would be quite anticlimactic. Throwing the chess board out there and having them play the game together? How more obvious could they make it? :lol: That kind of takes away from the suspense of Roger's search if they go there. But maybe obvious is what they are going for? :shrug:

I have actually been wondering about Anastasia. Maybe the girl is missing in HH because she has been lying in a coffin 6 ft under a garden, lol. Until Victoria dug her up. Didn't the name Eloise Gardener come up in Roger's investigation? 'Garden' can also be pulled put of that last name. Sounds like that is the HH cursed name of whoever that is and Alice already has her cursed name, Tilly. Unless they are throwing us off with the name and it's not the name of his daughter. In a Pirate's Life, Lady T & Older!Wish Hook seemed to know each other from the past so I guess it's always a possibilty.

Yeah must admit it would take the suspense away from it a bit if it was Alice..

This is exactly my problem with it. :nod: That and the fact she has a closer relationship with rumple, and doesn't seem like Hook to me.

Agreed that they've made Alice too obvious. I like the idea that it might be Anastasia. He and Lady Tremaine obviously knew one another in the past.

If it is Alice, they put the clues in way too early..

Hook singing the lullaby to his daughter tonight :bawl:.....so beautiful :love: